PDA

View Full Version : Harmony Remote killer?


Cholly
02-22-08, 10:41 AM
I've been a longtime user of X10 products, so I was curious about the X10 IR10A Icon Remote. I already own several learning or programmable remotes, including a Harmony 676, a Home Theater Master MX-500 and a Sony RM-VL600, but they all miss the mark somewhere. At any rate, I decided to try the IR10A and received it in yesterday's mail. Setting it up using the remote's wizard is a snap. I was able to quickly set up the components in my bedroom: Vizio LCD TV, HD TiVo, Onkyo stereo receiver and Delphi Roady XT XM satellite radio receiver. The only component I wasn't able to set up from the remote's library was my Toshiba HD DVD player. I haven't gotten around to using the IR10A's learning capability to add the player.
So far, the only real disappointment I've found is the lack of allocation of Favorites by component (TV or TiVo). However, you can set up a ton of Favorites lists, and assign each list to a specific component. Also, the individual buttons are not backlit and the text for alternate assignments of buttons is difficult to see. These are all nits, however. In playing with the remote last night and again today, I can safely say it was worth the investment, and in many ways, it beats the Harmony and other high priced remotes. The backlit display is bright and very legible. The ability to assign logos to the Favorites screens is a great feature. The remote is fairly large in size and buttons are big, unlike the Harmony remotes. And the price can't be beat!


http://www.x10.com/icon_remote/ir10a_si_sale.html

Jason Nipp
02-22-08, 11:12 AM
Looks good.... Is it rechargeable like my 880?

Cholly
02-22-08, 11:29 AM
Looks good.... Is it rechargeable like my 880?

It uses 3 AA batteries. Comes with 3 alkalines (which it recommends). I haven't seen anything about whether it would accommodate NiMH batteries. No charger capability.

One thing I failed to mention - it is very TiVo friendly, unlike my Harmony.

BudShark
02-22-08, 11:35 AM
In honor of Drew2k...

What?!? No color buttons? Ewww.... ;)

Looks good. I just bought a Harmony One, but this X10 remote seems nice.

Chris

smiddy
02-22-08, 12:25 PM
No recharger, no go...the reason I moved to the 890 was the recharging capability, since I was going through batteries it seemed weekly. I use my 890 throughout my house, and it has an RF extended for my media closet, which I couldn't do without. So...to exclain what BudShark has done above, the cool goodie would be color buttons...no change fer me.

redfiver
02-22-08, 12:31 PM
This is the harmony I want, just need to get it in the US! It has the color buttons in the right place!


http://www.logitech.com/index.cfm/remotes/universal_remotes/devices/370&cl=au,en

Cholly
02-22-08, 02:24 PM
Ummm ... color buttons? Excuse my ignorance, but what would they be for? My 676 doesn't have any durned color buttons. :D :confused:
You can define any of the ten buttons alongside the LCD just as you can with a Harmony remote.

Sirshagg
02-22-08, 02:30 PM
Ummm ... color buttons? Excuse my ignorance, but what would they be for? My 676 doesn't have any durned color buttons. :D :confused:
You can define any of the ten buttons alongside the LCD just as you can with a Harmony remote.

Some people (myself included) prefer hard color buttons.

gteach26
02-22-08, 03:19 PM
This is the harmony I want, just need to get it in the US! It has the color buttons in the right place!


http://www.logitech.com/index.cfm/remotes/universal_remotes/devices/370&cl=au,en

Whoa! That's a nice remote... seems better than the 880 (which I LOVE).. why aren't these puppies in the US?? Can they be shiiped to US, and will they work?