24p: Is it overhype and in reality a video disaster?

[Lord Vader]

Interesting article here. (http://www.projectorcentral.com/judder_24p.htm)

[Sirshagg]

Interesting article.

[tcusta00]

Wow, that was very educational, thanks for the link. :)

[Lord Vader]

Kinda makes me wanna go back and see these motion judder effects. If I didn't notice them the first time I saw these movies in BD, why should I care about 24p then?

I wonder if it's because I've got an LED DLP HDTV and not, say, an LCD one, which is more prone to motion judder.

[gfrang]

Here is the way i see it, if movies are filmed at 24 fps then it is best to display it at that frame rate than use a 3:2 pulldown process that can only come close. Also 24p useless less bandwidth than 60p.

[barryb]

Great article... thanks for posting.

[sperho]

To complement the OP's linked article: http://hd24.com/dont_shudder_at_the_judder.htm

This one explains why in the theater, judder isn't quite as bad as 24p digital even though they are both 24 fps. Interesting indeed.