Who would be your pick for the Next Survivor All Stars?

[Ron Barry]

If you had your pick, who would be the 16 all stars choosen for the next show?

My picks are:

Woman
Jenna (Survivor 1)
Kelly (Survivor 1)
Alicia (Survivor 2)
Tina (Survivor 2)
Kathy (Survivor 4)
Shii Ann (Survivor 5)
Colleen (Survivor 1)
Joanna (Survivor 6)

Men
Rich (Survivor 1)
Rudy (Survivor 1)
Colby (Survivor 2)
Michael (Survivor 2)
Hunter (Survivor 4)
Mathew (Survivor 6)
Brian (Survivor 5)
Ethan (Survivor 3)

Alternates
Rob (Survivor 6)
Dave (Survivor 6)
Lex (Survivor 2)

[Ron Barry]

No takers on a allstar list?

[Danny R]

Personally I'd prefer not to have the previous winners on the All-Star game. They would be too obvious a boot choice for everyone.

That said, I think I'd prefer lots of cute and adorable women, and dirty and rascally men. ;)

Jenna (S6)
Shawna (S6)
Sarah (S4)
Neleh (S4)
Elisabeth (S2)
Jessie (S3)
Colleen (S1)
Susan (S1)

Rupert (S7)
Rob (S6)
Clay (S5)
Brian (S5)
Hunter (S4)
Rob (S4)
Michael (S2)
Rudy (S1)

[Ron Barry]

Interesting list... I find Clay, Neleh, Jessie and Susan very unusual choices. I tended to go with people that seem to make the show interesting and that actually were considered strong. that way it would be harder to eliminate weak and to choose alliances.

Jenna won dude and so did Brian. ;)

[Danny R]

Do'h! You're right. I ment to dump them. Probably replace Jenna with Shii Ann, and Brian with Pascal.

Jessie I think would make an interesting player when combined with other "sweetheart" players, as she might not be an obvious outcast. We only saw her two episodes, so we don't really know her well, and she's easy on the eyes. ;)

I just love Clay and Susan's personalities.

[Ron Barry]

LOL... I can't stand Clay and Susan. If I see here one more time I would throw-up. If she is on the all-star game it is going to be really hard to watch. I tend to not like to add people that tried to milk their 15 minutes of fame. Hunter is an exception because he seemed like a real strong player and got the boot because of his strength.

[Mark Holtz]

I just heard Susan Hawk doing a radio ad for Boomtown Casino in Reno the other day on the way to work.

I agree with the Michael and Rudy, but how as Pasquel who was on the final four, but was eliminated due to a tie vote and he pulled the elimination rock?

[Ron Barry]

The reason I did not put Pasqueal on the list was because he really did not do a lot to get to the end. Was one of those along for the ride players. It sucked what happend to him and how he was removed, but I just did not see him as the quality of player to warrent the list.

As a side note, When making the list I found it much harder to choose the guys. As you see I have Rob, Lex, and Dave as Alternates. Tough list for the guys.

[Wildfire_36]

I have to go back and look at pictures to actually pick. I remember faces not names for the most part, but I do know I would pick Rob (from last season), Susan and Rudy for sure.

I think they should pic one man and one woman from each show to make it fair. Then do a random drawing for the last spots.

[Ron Barry]

Nah... I think picking the 16 people that they feel are the top 16 in both stratagy and challanges should be the determining factor. I seriously doubts alliences would be held at the show level, but I could be wrong.

As for the random drawing, I disagree completely. This is suppose to be a All Start survivor, not a second chance show. You want the cream of the crop here and not people like Shawn (Survivor 1). THe worse survivor player next to the new top of the hill Osten.

I am actually surprised a number of people would like to see Susan back in. My take was she basically road Rich's coat tails to the end and then was stabbed in the back by Kelli. She then in the final coucel actually believed she played ethically.

That is what cracks me up. When the people get the boot and come back and say... "At least I played with high morals" ... when in reality they did not. There are very few people that have played with high morals and most of the ones that did did not make it to the final 4. Sue was definitely not one of them.... It is the nature of the game and in my opinion is to be expected.

Sorry for the Sue rant now back to rational.

I still feel it should be the best competitors that showed that they were willing to play the game and made moves when necessary. I tried to keep the coat tailers off my list. Then again maybe a missed a few.

That is my rational. And I respect wilds and Danny's too.. SHould be very intersting show...

Not to take anything away from Survivor 7.. Enjoying it a bunch just not happy with the Twist..

Oh... I suggest everyone read the chat transcripts of Osten and Shawn.. WOW.... Very strange indeed.

[Wildfire_36]

As for the random drawing, I disagree completely. This is suppose to be a All Start survivor, not a second chance show. You want the cream of the crop here and not people like Shawn (Survivor 1). THe worse survivor player next to the new top of the hill Osten.

I still feel it should be the best competitors that showed that they were willing to play the game and made moves when necessary. I tried to keep the coat tailers off my list. Then again maybe a missed a few.


But "who" would decide who the "best players" are. Everyone sees it differently. And by rights the "best players" should have won. I agree that the winners should not be allowed to come back and win again. They would be easy targets yes.

I think Susan played a great game. And I would love to see her back. Players like Osten will most likely turn down the offer at a second game.

If it is not a "second chance show" but an actual "All Stars" then the "stars" are the winners and 2nd place people. That would only be 14 people and would not make a good show in my opinion.

I think it should be up to an internet poll or something. Have the "people" vote who they want to see back again (out of people who have already agreed to come back if chosen" that way lame o's like Osten and those dorks from Africa will not be back.

[Ron Barry]

As for only the top people in the game....
Well they already stated that winning does not assure you of a spot. There are people that just kinda of fell into winning.... Ethan and vecipia come to mind.

As for an internet poll.....
that can be a scary thing. I think the people that are close to the show should make that decision.. I am sure they have a panel that is evaluating who deserves the spots... There are a lot of survivors that got the boot because they were strong. Just this show has Burton go in the first few weeks. If it was and internet poll, most likely we would have all the babes and hunks on the island. I know that would please Danny but might not result in the best game.

Dorks from Africa?
I only have one from that series.. Ethan was a strong player thought he faded at the end. I contributed the fade to the fact that he carried that one woman most of the show. I could easily replace him.. That show was the worse conditions of any of the survivors according to Jeff Probst.

[Danny R]

If Rupert is on All Stars, then I'm betting he gets voted off before whatever day today is for that show (I believe its taping currently). He didn't look all that haggard to me. Anybody else get that opinion?

[dfergie]

how about a survivor losers show, all first voted off of the tribes.

[dbkelly]

What about Big Tom? He was hilarious! Definitely made that season for me. And Rob, from last season. I agree they should limit previous winner besides IMHO, most didn't deserve to win. Look a Vee!! Come on! She deserves to be an All-Star about as much as Lil deserved to win S7. Brian on the other hand would be a great All-Star. His faithful lackey, Clay can stay at home though.

I may have to think about this more and post later. ... gotta go to work now!

[Lee L]

Danny, 2 intersting things I saw last night. One, Rupert talking about beating Richard Hatch and Jon saying that maybe his Granpa would die for All-Stars. Wonder if anything can be read into those comments?

Also, is it possible that All-Stars just finished and maybe Rupert did not make final 4? He looked about th esame weight as he did in Panama but maybe more muscular. A few days of R&R in the losers lodege will do wonders.

[Wildfire_36]

Jeff Probst looked like he wanted to strangle Jonny Fairplay for the All Star comment, could that possibly mean (PLEASE TELL ME NO!!!) that Jon made it into that game?!?!?!

I would have hurt myself!

Rupert did look tired, but not a total wreck, so I would think if he was on the game he did not make it tooo far.

[Curtis0620]

If Rupert is on All Stars, then I'm betting he gets voted off before whatever day today is for that show (I believe its taping currently). He didn't look all that haggard to me. Anybody else get that opinion?

Taping finished on December 11th.

[Ron Barry]

Jeff Probst looked like he wanted to strangle Jonny Fairplay for the All Star comment, could that possibly mean (PLEASE TELL ME NO!!!) that Jon made it into that game?!?!?!

I would have hurt myself!

Rupert did look tired, but not a total wreck, so I would think if he was on the game he did not make it tooo far.

If you go back and look at the Video from the previous tribal councels you will notice that Rubert did not look much different than he did on the island. If the all-start show was in Panama then huge weight loss would not have occurred so I don't think making the conclusion that he did not make it that far might not be accurate.

[Karl Foster]

Here's my list:

Women:
Helen (Thailand)
Kathy (Marquesas)
Deanna (Amazon)
Sandra (Panama)
Darrah (Panama)
Alicia (Australia)
Kelly (Original)
Elisabeth (Africa)

Men:
Rupert (Panama)
Tom (Africa)
Jon (Panama)
Rob (Amazon)
Lex (Africa)
Colby (Australia)
Hunter (Marquesas)
Gervasse (first season) - hey someone has to suck at the swimming challenges

[Ron Barry]

Interesting list Karl... I am very suprised at Darrah and Gervasse being on it.... and no Winners from the previous shows.