PDA

View Full Version : HDMI vs. Component...


Nick
09-13-07, 03:47 PM
...What's The Difference?

From Tom's Guide:
By: Mark Raby
September 11, 2007

Introduction

Amid a global spectrum of high definition format battles, none is so misunderstood as the debate between HDMI and component video. Some videophiles expect HDMI to completely outpace the "vintage" analog format, while true experts in the field know there are distinct advantages and disadvantages to each format. This article will give you a better idea of the technologies that make up these video formats, and prove that the differences are not as lopsided as you may think.

Assumptions That Mask The Facts

If you talk to any half-witted video enthusiast or ask an associate at your local big box retailer - bearing in mind that the two groups are pretty much the same - they'll unmistakably tell you that HDMI is better than component, case closed, end of story. This is just based on tired assumptions of the entire audio/visual industry. HDMI is based on a digital technology while component is analog, HDMI is a more recent development and HDMI costs more. Conventional wisdom says that newer formats are better, digital is always the best and a higher price tag equals higher quality. ...More @ TomsGuide.com (http://www.tomsguide.com/us/2007/09/11/hdmi_vs_component/)

Cholly
09-14-07, 09:25 AM
Hmmm - an oversimplification that doesn't address audio completely. Still, I use component output from my Series 3 TiVo because my HDTV has only one HDMI input, which I have connected to my HD DVD player.

aim2pls
09-14-07, 03:25 PM
...What's The Difference?

From Tom's Guide:
More @ TomsGuide.com (http://www.tomsguide.com/us/2007/09/11/hdmi_vs_component/)

more expensive ???? only IF you buy your cables fromthe box store ... check out walmart ...LOL ... i've seen HDMI cables (commercial grade) for as low as 3.49 for a 6 footer

spamstew
09-14-07, 03:54 PM
blah blah blah... I have both HDMI and Component connecting my HR20 and my Sammy. I cannot see any noticeable differences in picture quality. If you need to buy any cables go to the web. Cables at the Box Stores are WAAAY overpriced. I go to monoprice.com for all my cables.