1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Dish: Please DROP KAIT Ch 8 in Jonesboro

Discussion in 'General DISH™ Discussion' started by Lifesaver2000, Jul 2, 2013.

  1. Lifesaver2000

    Lifesaver2000 New Member

    20
    2
    Mar 12, 2012
    Donna, where do you get your information on what is on the Satellites? The list on this page:

    http://uplink.jameslong.name/locallist.html

    clearly shows that all locals in the Jonesboro DMA are in SD, and shows KAIT as SD on Sat 129. KAIT is not listed as being carried in any DMA outside of Jonesboro.

    Also, although you have an HD receiver, that does not mean everything you watch is in HD. The signal from the receiver to the TV may be 1080, but that is not the same as the KAIT signal being HD on the satellite downlink. I know for a fact (because I can receive it OTA directly to my HDTV) that KAIT only transmits a 720p signal, but even that is not carried on Dish (unless it was VERY recently changed and James' list hasn't been updated).
     
  2. Lifesaver2000

    Lifesaver2000 New Member

    20
    2
    Mar 12, 2012
    I just realized, I have been saying LATA where I should say DMA. Sorry, too much going on.

    Edit: once again tsmacro said what I was going to say.
     
  3. Lifesaver2000

    Lifesaver2000 New Member

    20
    2
    Mar 12, 2012
    tsmacro: the stretch thing does go on a lot. My inlaws have a small HDTV (about 37") and they keep it on zoom all the time, so the SD locals don't look much different than the actual HD channels. It is quite obvious though on a bigger tv.

    I will also mention that I know of at least four local dish users besides me, and they all have locals in SD. I also know a bunch of people who use an address outside this DMA so they can get the Little Rock locals, and don't mind a bit that they don't have KAIT since all there locals actually are HD.

    And on a final note. When I signed up for Dish, the plan I got clearly said that locals were a free bonus. So, I don't see they owe me any kind of rebate, no matter what the TV stations want to say.
     
  4. tsmacro

    tsmacro Hall Of Fame

    2,369
    56
    Apr 28, 2005
    East...
    Actually streching the picture ruined HD for me in the early days of HD tv's. I was over someones house oh something like 12 years ago, never had seen an HD tv before and behold he had this big ol widescreen projection HD tv that took up a big chunk of real estate in his living room. He was bragging on his HD picture and I was looking at it because to me the picture didn't really look all that clear, sure it was big but the people looked "funny" kinda plump and "wide". I mentioned this and was told by Mr. Ohsoproudofhistv that the reason it looked that way to me was because that's what the people "actually looked like in real life" and it was just because I was used to seeing people "squished and grainy" on an "old fashioned tv" and thats why the people looked "funny" to me. So after leaving there i thought why the heck would i ever I want to spend all that money on an HD tv when the picture looked like that? Of course later on i realized what I had witnessed that day was a person who had an SD picture stretched on their HD tv and didn't have a clue. Funny how many people will still do that just to "fill up" their tv screen and think they're watching HD.
     
  5. Willh

    Willh Legend

    226
    6
    Jan 1, 2009
    to me, most of these disputes over local stations are being caused by sports greed, which is where sports get greedy with fees to broadcast a sporting a event on a network and the network in turns does the same to get back some lost money by asking their non-owned and operated affiliates to ask for an increase in their carriage fees on the new contract after the old one expires. same with the network's owned and operated stations, they want that increase in fees too. so blame sports for most of the local channels disputes as sporting events get more and more expensive for their rights. and you wonder why ESPN is so expensive.
     
  6. Donna E

    Donna E New Member

    8
    0
    Jul 30, 2013
    Pocahontas,A...
    We do not have any kind of antenna hooked up, we were getting KAIT in full HD, when the news came on it even said in full HD, It was like being in the same room with the news casters, we have a 50" full 1080 HD flat screen television, it was awesome to watch the news on, we don't watch too many other KAIT programs but like keeping up with our local news and weather. I don't understand why people keep saying we were not watching KAIT in full HD, why would anyone lie about something like that? I know quite a few people with Dish Network who had KAIT in full HD, WITH NO ANTENNA OF ANY KIND..
     
  7. Donna E

    Donna E New Member

    8
    0
    Jul 30, 2013
    Pocahontas,A...
    I have also seen this, we actually have full 1080 HD, it is like being right where the action is, Dish Network has quite a few HD channels, why would anyone want to stretch an SD picture on an HD television?
     
  8. Donna E

    Donna E New Member

    8
    0
    Jul 30, 2013
    Pocahontas,A...
    I know what HD looks like, also when KAIT news comes on it says in full HD, I never said that everything is in HD, I said KAIT is in HD, we have had full HD with KAIT since we got Dish Network a year and a half ago, I really don't care if you believe me, we know what we were getting..
     
  9. SayWhat?

    SayWhat? Know Nothing

    6,259
    133
    Jun 6, 2009
    Their advertising logo doesn't mean Dish is rebroadcasting it that way.
     
  10. Lifesaver2000

    Lifesaver2000 New Member

    20
    2
    Mar 12, 2012
    Donna, please don't take things personally. I never said you are lying, but I do believe you are mistaken, based on the available information here and from Dish, all of which says that local programming in the Jonesboro DMA is in SD. And as SayWhat states, having the HD logo on screen does not mean things are actually in HD.

    Here is something to look for. When I watch KAIT over the air and with the TV screen aspect ratio set to normal, the news will fill the full 16:9 screen. This is also true for ABC network programming. But, when Wheel of Fortune comes on at 6:30, it will appear in a 4:3 aspect ratio box in the middle of the screen, filling the screen top to bottom but with black bars on the left and right. This is because KAIT transmits most of their non-network programming other than news programs in a 4:3 format.

    If you see both the News and Wheel of fortune filling the entire screen, then you have the aspect ratio stretched or zoomed as someone above mentioned, most likely because it is an SD signal being stretched to fill the HD screen.

    I will say again that nobody accused anyone of lying, but I do know that in my 35 years of working with electronics, home entertainment and computers I have come across many non-technical people that don't really understand how these kinds of things work. There is nothing wrong with that. There are lots of things I don't know anything about. But as I said above, all the available evidence states that KAIT is NOT available in HD on Dish Network.

    And if you don't believe me, go to this web page: http://www.dish.com/entertainment/channels/local/?WT.svl=main-content

    and enter your ZIP code. Dish itself lists all of the local channels as being in SD. Why would THEY lie?
     
  11. Donna E

    Donna E New Member

    8
    0
    Jul 30, 2013
    Pocahontas,A...
    All I know is that when we watch KAIT it is in HD, the picture is not stretched, that is why we went with Dish in the first place, they told us it would be in full HD..
     
  12. tsmacro

    tsmacro Hall Of Fame

    2,369
    56
    Apr 28, 2005
    East...
    She could be right, if you look up the following zip code: 13905 you'll find that they list the Binghamton, NY DMA as being in SD only. I happen to know from James Long's uplink report that a month or two ago that they added HD locals, that and I grew up in that area so I know some people there so I checked with them and sure enough they do have HD locals even though the Dish site says no, that and if you call Dish they'll tell you they don't have them even though they do. She seems to understand what the difference between an HD picture looks like and a stretched and or zoomed one so it's possible it really is in HD. I like you was trying to figure out how that was possible considering the evidence against it but ultimately she's there and we're not.
     
  13. Lifesaver2000

    Lifesaver2000 New Member

    20
    2
    Mar 12, 2012
    tsmacro, I am in the Jonesboro DMA, just a few miles from Donna, and there are no locals in HD.
     
    1 person likes this.
  14. James Long

    James Long Ready for Uplink! Staff Member Super Moderator DBSTalk Club

    45,306
    913
    Apr 17, 2003
    Michiana
    The named station in question, KAIT, is not carried in HD via DISH network satellites.

    It is not there. One cannot receive via DISH something that they do not transmit.
     
    1 person likes this.
  15. jsk

    jsk Icon

    776
    11
    Dec 27, 2006
    If Aero prevails in all of their lawsuits, then maybe Dish will start integrating that technology in their receivers and these retrans battles will be a thing of the past. I'm sure that will result in more lawsuits, but Charlie would welcome the challenge. Heck, I'm surprised that Charlie didn't buy Aero so he could be involved in another lawsuit.
     
  16. Lifesaver2000

    Lifesaver2000 New Member

    20
    2
    Mar 12, 2012
    James, thank you. If anyone knows it would be you. I was actually hoping I was wrong, because that would mean I could start getting my locals in HD. Maybe some day.

    I will say that this discussion brings up something else, namely the misinformation and impossible promises that are thrown out by some (hopefully very few) less-than-completely-honest installers, whether it be Dish, Direct or cable. These bad ones surely make it hard on the rest.

    I am lucky that my Dish installer is someone with whom I work in my normal public safety related job, and I could trust I would get what I was told. If anything, my Dish service has exceeded my expectations (I know, not something you hear often).

    In my area, I am "That Guy," the one people will call up at random with computer or electronics questions. I have seen some pretty unbelievable setups. Like the people who think that adding two speakers in the back of the room wired in to the same output channels as the front speakers gives them surround sound. Or the guy who thinks that he is watching HDTV with a DVD player plugged in via a composite input. Sometimes I almost hate to tell them what they really have, because they seem so happy just "knowing" that it is surround or HD.

    More than once I have had to go in to someone's house, completely disconnect EVERYTHING and start wiring up the TV, Stereo and audio/video sources from scratch, sometimes changing things people have been using for a long time. Of course, when they see what their system can really look/sound like, it is a mix of "wow, I didn't know it could be that good" and "you mean I have been missing out on this all this time?"

    The point is, there are many good people out there that are lied to and taken advantage of when it comes to home entertainment, and that is why when I see this kind of thing I try so hard to set the record straight. I hope nobody has been hurt or offended by anything I have said here.
     
  17. Davenlr

    Davenlr Geek til I die

    9,136
    27
    Sep 16, 2006
  18. jrcart

    jrcart Cool Member

    31
    1
    Oct 17, 2008
    We moved to the Jonesboro area from Woodruff Co. a couple of years ago. In Woodruff Co. We received the Little Rock locals in HD. When we moved to Jonesboro we had Dish installed here and of course could not get the locals in HD. Plus we were not able to get the Little Rock locals either. Very disappointed! It didn't take long for us to switch to Directv because the locals were in HD. The only problem with that was KAIT is the only Arkansas station we could get. The other stations are in Kentucky or in Missouri. What I would like to see is that somehow a law could get passed to allow us to get any local that is available in their spot beam that we wanted.
     
  19. Lifesaver2000

    Lifesaver2000 New Member

    20
    2
    Mar 12, 2012
    jrcart, I agree on the law change. Locals should at least stay within the state. If you are in Jonesboro, the Memphis stations do include your area in their news and weather coverage. Over here in the western part of the Jonesboro DMA, without KAIT we have NO local weather coverage. That means nothing on Dish right now would cover us in the event of severe weather, unless The Weather Channel happened to mention it. On the other hand, the Little Rock stations cover the entire state.

    Seems kind of weird that when big news happens there will be two or three news vans from Little Rock stations, none from Memphis, but then we get Memphis stations. Makes no sense to me.

    Of course, as I've mentioned I have KAIT OTA. And since I got a weather radio I really haven't depended on the TV for weather info. But I know a lot of people that do.
     
    1 person likes this.

Share This Page