Okay kids.. 14 years with Directv.. many highs and a couple of lows.. but today is the shocker.. My dvr in the kitchen stopped showing a picture.. it showed the channels and the banners at the top.. but no photo.. and last night in the middle of the night. I had a freeze up in an HBO movie.. ( never had that happen before) so I call. and later was just asking nicely if I could get Showtime for a couple of months.. The CSR that I spoke to.. immediately gave me a discount on HBO and Stars and then said her cpu was running slow.. Finally she says yes my supervisor gave you the showtime.. No biggie..
but whenever I call I always make sure that my Distants are still there. and they were.. but for WHAT EVER REASON IN THE WORLD.. I checked my locals.. WWWWHHHHAAAAAAATTT!!!! they were on.. didn't ask. didn't mention.. didn't imply, hint , discuss , or even ask about the weather in my local area.. Now what? after 14 years I should be Shreva Grandfathered.. but .. the picture quality was just what I expected.. NO LOCAL HD..( CBS LOCAL NO HD). no stereo.. I do not want to give up my distants.. No flippn' way.. I suppose the best thing to do is to sit and wait.. but right now I am shocked.. ( Claude Rains , Casablanca, 1942 102 min)
I can almost guarantee she changed your package from a base package with no locals to the equivalent base package with locals, which will increase your bill slightly (the cost of the locals ).
Okay kids.. 14 years with Directv.. many highs and a couple of lows.. but today is the shocker.. My dvr in the kitchen stopped showing a picture.. it showed the channels and the banners at the top.. but no photo.. and last night in the middle of the night. I had a freeze up in an HBO movie.. ( never had that happen before) so I call. and later was just asking nicely if I could get Showtime for a couple of months.. The CSR that I spoke to.. immediately gave me a discount on HBO and Stars and then said her cpu was running slow.. Finally she says yes my supervisor gave you the showtime.. No biggie..
but whenever I call I always make sure that my Distants are still there. and they were.. but for WHAT EVER REASON IN THE WORLD.. I checked my locals.. WWWWHHHHAAAAAAATTT!!!! they were on.. didn't ask. didn't mention.. didn't imply, hint , discuss , or even ask about the weather in my local area.. Now what? after 14 years I should be Shreva Grandfathered.. but .. the picture quality was just what I expected.. NO LOCAL HD..( CBS LOCAL NO HD). no stereo.. I do not want to give up my distants.. No flippn' way.. I suppose the best thing to do is to sit and wait.. but right now I am shocked.. ( Claude Rains , Casablanca, 1942 102 min)
I can almost guarantee she changed your package from a base package with no locals to the equivalent base package with locals, which will increase your bill slightly (the cost of the locals ).
I don't get locals either. But would like to know his/her location also. They will come on automatically when available I've been told. But like I said they shouldn't have CBS without HD if the others are in HD.
I don't get locals either. But would like to know his/her location also. They will come on automatically when available I've been told. But like I said they shouldn't have CBS without HD if the others are in HD.
I think the law is carry one, carry all. DIRECTV des not have to carry any local in HD, but if the carry one then they have to offer to carry all (those that are available). At least this is how I understand it. Pretty sure corrections will follow.
Okay kids.. 14 years with Directv.. many highs and a couple of lows.. but today is the shocker.. My dvr in the kitchen stopped showing a picture.. it showed the channels and the banners at the top.. but no photo.. and last night in the middle of the night. I had a freeze up in an HBO movie.. ( never had that happen before) so I call. and later was just asking nicely if I could get Showtime for a couple of months.. The CSR that I spoke to.. immediately gave me a discount on HBO and Stars and then said her cpu was running slow.. Finally she says yes my supervisor gave you the showtime.. No biggie..
but whenever I call I always make sure that my Distants are still there. and they were.. but for WHAT EVER REASON IN THE WORLD.. I checked my locals.. WWWWHHHHAAAAAAATTT!!!! they were on.. didn't ask. didn't mention.. didn't imply, hint , discuss , or even ask about the weather in my local area.. Now what? after 14 years I should be Shreva Grandfathered.. but .. the picture quality was just what I expected.. NO LOCAL HD..( CBS LOCAL NO HD). no stereo.. I do not want to give up my distants.. No flippn' way.. I suppose the best thing to do is to sit and wait.. but right now I am shocked.. ( Claude Rains , Casablanca, 1942 102 min)
I think the law is carry one, carry all. DIRECTV des not have to carry any local in HD, but if the carry one then they have to offer to carry all (those that are available). At least this is how I understand it. Pretty sure corrections will follow.
I think the law is carry one, carry all. DIRECTV des not have to carry any local in HD, but if the carry one then they have to offer to carry all (those that are available). At least this is how I understand it. Pretty sure corrections will follow.
We need to know the market. If the market's CBS affiliate is not broadcasting in HD they would not need to be carried in HD. (And by broadcasting I mean OTA transmission ... not some special HD feed to cable systems.) CBS is a bigger network and typically a CBS affiliate will be HD, but without knowing the market an absolute statement would be wrong.
The OP's comment about "no local HD" ... are any of his locals carried in HD? He mentions CBS but states "no local HD". This is where the "carry one carry all" rule for HD comes into play ... DIRECTV is not required to carry every market in HD. If they carry one of that market's stations in HD they must offer HD carriage to all stations (even unpopular ones) in HD. But if no local station is carried in HD they are not required to provide HD carriage.
Again, knowing the exact market would help. If the poster is in a market that DIRECTV only carries in SD then he would get all of his local stations in SD.
The distants issue adds additional confusion. The laws have changed several times over the past decades and having some customers under old rules and others under older rules while new customers cannot get distants in markets with locals is complicated.
The one final comment I will make is that DIRECTV is not required to offer distants. They could pull the service from any or all customers at any time. There is no law that requires distants be offered. The laws prohibit providing distants in most cases and protect providing distants in narrow cases but no law requires distants be delivered.
Well not really. There are plenty of situations where one channel may not be Hi Definition. They also would still need a contract to carry it in Hi Definition as well. Although today you'd think any contract would include both Hi Definition and SD but you never now.
Well not really. There are plenty of situations where one channel may not be Hi Definition. They also would still need a contract to carry it in Hi Definition as well. Although today you'd think any contract would include both Hi Definition and SD but you never now.
Just look at the LIL tab on Gary's transponder maps in the Tips forum. There's multiple markets where some of their networks are SD only, especially in some smaller markets where some networks reside on subchannels. Just to name a few, Fairbanks, Juneau and Great Falls if you only count the big 4, a lot more when you include PBS, The CW and MyNetworkTV
The op never gave their location, so we can't lookup their market.
Just look at the LIL tab on Gary's transponder maps in the Tips forum. There's multiple markets where some of their networks are SD only, especially in some smaller markets where some networks reside on subchannels. Just to name a few, Fairbanks, Juneau and Great Falls if you only count the big 4, a lot more when you include PBS, The CW and MyNetworkTV
The op never gave their location, so we can't lookup their market.
That's not the issue, I know there are several smaller markets without HD. You will notice they are all SD not mixed. But if any market has 1 HD on any of these ( ABC,FOX,CBS,NBC) it has to provide at least 1 HD of the other networks.
Okay kids.. 14 years with Directv.. many highs and a couple of lows.. but today is the shocker.. My dvr in the kitchen stopped showing a picture.. it showed the channels and the banners at the top.. but no photo.. and last night in the middle of the night. I had a freeze up in an HBO movie.. ( never had that happen before) so I call. and later was just asking nicely if I could get Showtime for a couple of months.. The CSR that I spoke to.. immediately gave me a discount on HBO and Stars and then said her cpu was running slow.. Finally she says yes my supervisor gave you the showtime.. No biggie..
but whenever I call I always make sure that my Distants are still there. and they were.. but for WHAT EVER REASON IN THE WORLD.. I checked my locals.. WWWWHHHHAAAAAAATTT!!!! they were on.. didn't ask. didn't mention.. didn't imply, hint , discuss , or even ask about the weather in my local area.. Now what? after 14 years I should be Shreva Grandfathered.. but .. the picture quality was just what I expected.. NO LOCAL HD..( CBS LOCAL NO HD). no stereo.. I do not want to give up my distants.. No flippn' way.. I suppose the best thing to do is to sit and wait.. but right now I am shocked.. ( Claude Rains , Casablanca, 1942 102 min)
That's not the issue, I know there are several smaller markets without HD. You will notice they are all SD not mixed. But if any market has 1 HD on any of these ( ABC,FOX,CBS,NBC) it has to provide at least 1 HD of the other networks.
The rule only applies to primary feeds of full powered commercial stations. If the network is on a subchannel or a low powered station they don't have to offer HD carriage, even if the OTA feed is HD.
It gets even more complicated when Retrans consent is involved instead of must carry. It means that they have to negotiate the rights to carry the channel in HD before they can add it in HD, even if they already carry the channel in SD. When HD locals first went live many markets were missing random stations because of this. (i.e. here in Wilkes-Barre when HD locals were added, NBC and CBS wasn't carried in HD until they renewed their deal)
In Fairbanks, the CBS affiliation is with a class A station and not a full powered station, over the air that channel is HD, on DirecTV it's SD only. In Great Falls, Fox is on subchannel of the ABC affiliate, over the air it's in HD, on DirecTV it's SD only.
Most of the subchannel affiliates are relatively new, usually when the contract comes up for renewal of the main channel, HD carriage of the subchannel affiliate is included. (i.e. the upcoming NBC Boston who's main feed is going to be a low power station in Boston and will also be carried on a subchannel of the Telemundo affiliate in southern New Hampshire, HD Carriage and channel positioning for that was included as part of the recent NBCU renewal for both DirecTV and Dish)
That's not the issue, I know there are several smaller markets without HD. You will notice they are all SD not mixed. But if any market has 1 HD on any of these ( ABC,FOX,CBS,NBC) it has to provide at least 1 HD of the other networks.
We need to know the market. If the market's CBS affiliate is not broadcasting in HD they would not need to be carried in HD. (And by broadcasting I mean OTA transmission ... not some special HD feed to cable systems.) CBS is a bigger network and typically a CBS affiliate will be HD, but without knowing the market an absolute statement would be wrong.
The OP's comment about "no local HD" ... are any of his locals carried in HD? He mentions CBS but states "no local HD". This is where the "carry one carry all" rule for HD comes into play ... DIRECTV is not required to carry every market in HD. If they carry one of that market's stations in HD they must offer HD carriage to all stations (even unpopular ones) in HD. But if no local station is carried in HD they are not required to provide HD carriage.
Again, knowing the exact market would help. If the poster is in a market that DIRECTV only carries in SD then he would get all of his local stations in SD.
The distants issue adds additional confusion. The laws have changed several times over the past decades and having some customers under old rules and others under older rules while new customers cannot get distants in markets with locals is complicated.
The one final comment I will make is that DIRECTV is not required to offer distants. They could pull the service from any or all customers at any time. There is no law that requires distants be offered. The laws prohibit providing distants in most cases and protect providing distants in narrow cases but no law requires distants be delivered.
What allows him in this case to keep both is that the law says if you had DNS before locals were launched in your DMA, you are grandfathered in and can keep both. Since there are so few with DNS feeds anymore and it is harder and harder to get a DNS station, this does not apply to many anymore.
I personally have both DNS stations and my DMA's locals but I had DNS feeds before the DMA's locals were launched as well. They come in super handy. Love having them.
Do not forget that the law applies to DIRECTV. The law *allows* DIRECTV to deliver distant networks in narrowly defined cases (including grandfathered customers - under narrowly defined conditions) but does not *require* that DIRECTV deliver distant networks to any customer.
I have to say that Josh and I will never have our discussion again.. For the past.. five or six years.. always in September, we discuss whether or not I should get my locals.. and I kept putting it off.. I have to say that I gained at least one football game this Sunday.. I will also say that I am still using the 390's channels instead of my locals.. the quality is far superior.. and I will again say that my invoice still says with out locals.. and I am not going to call and tell them.. I will use them in case of severe weather or some other instance but for nothing else.. just remember I joined when Pegasus was still trying to sell Directv in my general area...that's how far back I go.. and had I known that there were the distant networks back in the day.. I would have joined Directv 10 years before that .. because that's how long I looked at them..
If someday Directv ever gets all markets launched, I would not be one bit surprised if they just end having DNS feeds all together... While bandwidth isn't an issue, that would free up another 8 hd and sd channels nationally...
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Related Threads
?
?
?
?
?
DBSTalk Forum
3.6M posts
112K members
Since 2001
A forum community dedicated to digital bit streaming enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about programming, content, and reception, home theaters, displays, models, styles, satellites, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more!