I voted yes - I would trade, however it is a very qualified vote. I would trade only if that means I would get MRV, DLB, 30 second skip and the ability to extract shows and put them on my ipod. And, I also still want mpeg4, a faster UI and the 2-push series record. So - would I trade my HR20 for a HR10? No. Would I get an "HR30" that had the advantages of both? Absolutely!