So, I'm making the big switch from SD to HD, and I know I won't be able to live without a DVR. I've been waiting for the HR20 and Series 3 to come out before I take the plunge. So, I know it's a little premature to make comparisons (since the Series 3 is still unreleased, and all of 2 people on this board have HR20s), but I'd still like to hear people's thoughts. The battle: DTV and the HR20-700 vs. Series 3 TiVo and Comcast My important criteria, in rough priority order: 1) Quality of interface/ease of use 2) Programming choice, especially HD. I know Sunday Ticket is the killer app for a lot of people here, and it's something I would get (especially with Superfan/HD games) but lack of ST is not a deal breaker. 3) Picture quality 4) Costs FWIW, I am a current DTV sub, with a ReplayTV DVR. I'm more-or-less happy with the RTV now (my first two units had to be returned, and the software was EXTREMELY buggy for a while, though much less so now). The 30-sec skip feature on the RTV is very nicely implemented. And my wife can use the RTV without me having to run it for her.