1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Polk Audio? JBL? Or something else?

Discussion in 'Home Theater Audio' started by ron mexico75, Jun 21, 2013.

  1. zx10guy

    zx10guy AllStar

    111
    0
    Nov 16, 2008
    I wonder how many of those that profess to care about sound quality actually go the full distance in having proper speaker placement and acoustically treating their rooms.
     
  2. MysteryMan

    MysteryMan Well-Known Member DBSTalk Club

    8,318
    459
    May 17, 2010
    USA
    Guilty!...... When I had my Home Theater Room built acoustics and speaker placement were a priority.
     
    1 person likes this.
  3. zx10guy

    zx10guy AllStar

    111
    0
    Nov 16, 2008
    :up:
     
  4. lugnutathome

    lugnutathome Hall Of Fame

    3,003
    108
    Apr 13, 2009
    Woodburn, OR
    I make my home purchase decisions around being able to utilize proper speaker placement and acoustical treating along with equalization parameters are essential but the OP here wants to know about soundbars and despite the fact that most are a poor substitute for the real thing, there is reasons where one may be compelled to use one in which case the upper end Yamaha YSP line offers an amazing soundstage.

    I went with the YSP in my master bedroom because speaker placement options was nowhere near optimal and it would have been a complete remodel to run surround wires hidden. My master bedroom is 736 sqft with high vaulted ceilings. Its layout is such that I have a 23 ft depth from back wall to front wall and 32 ft "width" with a reclining sofa at the foot of the bed for consuming the AV experience. The TV sits on a raised tilted platform above the soundbar atop a 48 inch high fireplace mantle fortunately centered. A very non optimal environment made quite enjoyable by the YSP's ability to set its parameters to the room.

    Is it league with a high end 5 or 7.1 system? No. It can't offer the discrete locational nuances a real speaker deployment can. OTOH, it offers a very wide soundstage, good full bodied sound and I put it ahead of the HTIAB level and about in line with real systems using constrained satellite speaker systems.

    Its amplifier per speaker and beam calibration create phantom speakers around the room! If you walk around you can hear what seems a speaker at the points where one should be. It is just reflection off the walls! Because it is launched from the front if it is a sole sound emission not hidden within other sounds you might catch the launch and the reflection. But on an action film soundtrack HOOO BOY! One would be hard pressed to tell it wasn't a full 5 or 7.1 system. Now in my case its a 42 speaker array with 2 additional L/R tweeters plus a 12 in Polk sub and an MSRP of almost 2,200 dollars but its abilities within my room constraints make it an ideal solution for the situation. Short of hiding wires, re mudding and texturing drywall, repainting, etc. (which leads to new carpets, drapes, linens) :-(

    These other soundbar wanabes that offer a 5 or 7 speaker array cannot begin to compare. But they can in a normal sized room offer a rich central speaker that gives sound far better than the TV speakers which in some peoples minds is all they want. In some cases they could use the TV analog audio out to feed a nice PC 2.1 speaker system and be just as happy.

    Don "if everbody was an audio snob what would the world be like?" Bolton
     
  5. zx10guy

    zx10guy AllStar

    111
    0
    Nov 16, 2008
    Don,

    The point of my post wasn't to hold the OP to task about his decision to go with a sound bar. It's with some of the responders to this thread criticizing him for his choice. I wanted to know of those that were harsh in their replies have themselves done what is required to really get proper acoustical reproduction in their listening environments. I too can go on and on with my equipment choices and how I've set up my main listening room. But I don't. And even with having a dedicated sound room with acoustical treatments, dedicated power runs with balanced power transformers, etc, etc, I have even considered the use of a sound bar in my other system in the family room. There are times when I look at my system and wish I didn't have to turn on all the various components just to casually watch TV. If I can find a sound bar which meets most of my requirements, I would have one installed and wouldn't give it a second thought with it along side the 2 channel system I have in there (B&W Nautilus 805, Velodyne HGS12II, Velodyne SMS-1, Bryston BP25, Emotiva XPA-2, VPI HW19Jr MKIII and Audioquest PT9 tone arm/Sumiko BluePoint, and Classe CDP .3.)
     
  6. P Smith

    P Smith Mr. FixAnything

    21,596
    143
    Jul 25, 2002
    W.Mdtrn Sea
    guys, when you posing your equipment, pleas add its price next to the name ;)
     
  7. zx10guy

    zx10guy AllStar

    111
    0
    Nov 16, 2008
    Well, paying top dollar for expensive equipment doesn't guarantee that you'll get every dollar spent in acoustical performance. I've had many debates with others about this and have held my tongue on numerous occasions when someone posts pictures of some speakers they've spent $20,000 a pair for; to end up flushing that investment down the toilet when they shove those speakers into a corner sandwiched by a bulky home entertainment system. That to me is a bigger travesty than someone who just buys a home theater in a box system.
     
  8. ron mexico75

    ron mexico75 Cool Member

    171
    2
    Jan 7, 2012
    Wow..........so no JBL and no Polk audio then. I don't want a true surround system that's why I asked which one would be better. I was hoping some people that were knowledgeable about these things could help me choose.
     
  9. ron mexico75

    ron mexico75 Cool Member

    171
    2
    Jan 7, 2012
    Wow..........so no JBL and no Polk audio then. I don't want a true surround system that's why I asked which one would be better. I was hoping some people that were knowledgeable about these things could help me choose.
     
  10. ron mexico75

    ron mexico75 Cool Member

    171
    2
    Jan 7, 2012
    Wow..........so no JBL and no Polk audio then. I don't want a true surround system that's why I asked which one would be better. I was hoping some people that were knowledgeable about these things could help me choose.
     
  11. P Smith

    P Smith Mr. FixAnything

    21,596
    143
    Jul 25, 2002
    W.Mdtrn Sea
    wow ! triple posts ? perhaps delete it ?
     
  12. peds48

    peds48 Genius. DBSTalk Club

    19,101
    993
    Jan 10, 2008
    NY
    Don,

    It's with some of the responders to this thread criticizing him for his choice. I


    The TS came to this site for some advice or opinions. I gave mine, I was never trying to criticize the TS for his choice. That is why I stayed out of this thread since I don't have any sound bar "experience"
     
  13. lugnutathome

    lugnutathome Hall Of Fame

    3,003
    108
    Apr 13, 2009
    Woodburn, OR
    Hey if my sig started a war I apologize.

    I was really trying to point out that there are some reasons where such devices do fill the bill to where even I had to lower my standards for a particular instance. I am most persnickity about my AV equipment.

    Anyhow no disrepect intended.

    Don "self confessed audio snob" Bolton
     
  14. ron mexico75

    ron mexico75 Cool Member

    171
    2
    Jan 7, 2012
    wow ! triple posts ? perhaps delete it ?


    I tried 3 times to delete and it said deleted.
     
  15. P Smith

    P Smith Mr. FixAnything

    21,596
    143
    Jul 25, 2002
    W.Mdtrn Sea
    still here ... I would open each one and delete again
     
  16. CCarncross

    CCarncross Hall Of Fame

    7,058
    60
    Jul 19, 2005
    Jackson
    ron I gotta say it looks like you spend most of your time reading other people's reviews and buying based on other people's opinions rather than picking a few models based on reviews and opinions and going to evaluate them yourselves. Seems like an easy way to buy something that may not suit your individual tastes. The research part you do is great, but I would never buy any tv "sight unseen" or audio equipment "sound unheard", thats just asking for trouble.
     
  17. inkahauts

    inkahauts Well-Known Member

    21,940
    1,011
    Nov 13, 2006
    To add to what you said, I would say sound is even mor difficult than picture, because so many people hear different frequencies and speakers have such different pitches to them.
     
  18. jimmie57

    jimmie57 Hall Of Fame

    6,618
    316
    Jun 26, 2010
    Texas City, TX
    It is very possible that the TS was having trouble like I was. For the last couple of days sometimes I could not even open the forum web site. Also, when I was on the web site at time and I clicked the back button it would do nothing ( Using IE 10 ), When I clicked the down arrow next to the Back / Forward buttons the window that opens was full of things with google-analytics in it.
    I went into Internet options , Security Privacy and added www.google-analytics.com to the list with a Block. I also deleted all temporary files that had that name in them. So far I have not had any more problems.
     
  19. MysteryMan

    MysteryMan Well-Known Member DBSTalk Club

    8,318
    459
    May 17, 2010
    USA
    Same here. For the past few days I've experienced the same using both Internet Explorer 10 and Google Chrome.
     
  20. bnwrx

    bnwrx Icon

    1,096
    34
    Dec 29, 2007
    colorado,...
    I've had and thoroughly enjoyed my NHT SuperZero's for over 15 years now. Still reasonably priced at $99 (whole system for around $850) People who visit us are also very impressed with their performance for their size.
    Just sayin......
     

Share This Page