Separate names with a comma.
Discussion in 'DIRECTV HD DVR/Receiver Discussion' started by westview, Feb 29, 2012.
What does Tivo do that is better than a DVR?
Tivo is a DVR.
I think the OP means "better than an HR series DVR".
I think it's really a matter of personal opinion and which interface you like better. The TiVo can record things based on what it thinks you "like" but I think that's really all it can do that the HR series can't.
There's quite a bit more the new TiVo CAN'T do that the HR series can and that, I think, is quite a drawback.
Tivo is an interface, a way to work a DVR.
Some people like the way an Apple computer works more than one which uses Windows.
It's like that.
Is it better? Now that's a matter of opinion.
You can find out a lot of information about the HD DIRECTV TiVo here: http://www.dbstalk.com/showthread.php?t=199680
Unlimited season passes (series links), swivel search, ability to use IR and RF remote at the same time, smoother 1x trickplay, and OTA channel scanning.
Damn, I knew I was forgetting something! :lol:
SOme people like Mac's some prefer pc's..there are a few functional differences as pointed out above...most of the difference is preferences, some people just have to have that Tivo interface. some of us think it sux....:lol:
But hey, different strokes for different folks. I think it's great you can get both.
I doubt that Tivo can do "smoother 1x trickplay" or more accurately FFWDx1 at 30 fps with MPEG-4 content, as the reason it is not smooth in the HR series is primarily a limitation of MPEG-4 itself.
On the other hand, I hope that they can prove me wrong on that count; it really depends on whether the decoder chip has improved enough, so we can't rule that out technically, and at some point the newer DVRs will indeed be able to handle MPEG-4 more smoothly, at lease we can hope.
But the older HR10-250 at least had a time bar backdoor that would allow clearing the time bar on pause or play in half a second, which is very nice and convenient.
Tivo also does not use the "press and hold" approach to slomo, but a dedicated button making it much more elegant than on the HRs.
Tivo has always had pretty good reliability comparatively speaking. I would use the term "rock solid" if not for their gigantic stumble with v6.x, which was not at all stable for some time and never really regained the stability level of 3.1.5. after 5 up revs attempted that. Even with that hanging over them, it was rare to miss a recording or lose a recording on Tivo. That used to be the case with the HR series from about 2008 to 2010, but they have broken that and are not as reliable in that regard as they once were.
I always liked the fact that search and SPs based on search were done better on Tivo; I miss that. Tivo also has the fuzzy logic "suggestions", but the system seems to run better without suggestions or thumb ratings; sonce they add little user friendliness it is better to not use those features in my experience.
Tivo has no PIG, which to me is a huge advantage; I hate the intrusiveness of the PIG on the HRs. Not sure about the new DTivo in that regard.
But (and I know this is a separate thread issue) the HRs seem to have a lot of unique advantages of their own, including automatic same-channel or 1-tuner padding, which is a deal-breaker for me (won't buy a DVR without that). It used to take anywhere from 12 to 20 button presses to turn on CC or turn it back off on Tivo.
In many ways that is an acceptable analogy, but I take issue comparing Tivo or the HRs to Macs, as that really lowers the level of respect that Macs and other Apple products deserve. They should not be diminished by such a comparison. Even Tivo is no Apple, which is the highest-valued company for a very good reason. Right, all you haters?
And yes, once you get used to the HR, it does seem that certain aspects of the Tivo approach do suck by comparison, IMHO.
My main issued with the DirecTv Tivos is the incompatibility with Whole Home.
Had I not seen it myself I'd be as skeptical as you.
What about us Linux guys?
That's very cool, Stu. For once I am starting to finally have some interest in the new DTivo if it can do that. Are we talking full blown AVC the way DTV encodes it or smaller H.264 files from youtube?
Does it need to be connected to a phone line like the old Hughes 40 hour dvr's? Also is it SWM capable?
Never had the question from my lovely wife, "Why is it doing that?" regarding all the glitches on the HR units. TiVo just works all the time every time.
No, it doesn't and you just refuse to admit it. You're the only long time Tivo owner who's NEVER had a Tivo freeze.
You fall into category #3