Welcome to DBSTalk
- Start new topics and reply to others
- Subscribe to topics and forums to get email updates
- Get your own profile page and make new friends
- Send personal messages to other members.
CommScope 5740 vs. 5781 RG6Q ???
Posted 15 February 2003 - 01:35 PM
Yesterday I received 500ft of CommScope 5740 from Cable-X-Perts for $75. [minus s&h], it would appear that 5740 is a discontinued line as the official CommScope website doesn't even list it. I could have gotten 1000ft of the CommScope 5781 direct from the manufacturer for $90 [minus s&h], but to be honest I didn't need 1000ft or have the extra cash for item and additional shipping.
So I am wondering what would have been the realized benefit anyway? I know the 5781 has a solid copper conductor verses the copper covered steel of the 5740, but there are advantages to each. I am wondering what the difference between Aluminum Braid and 3 or 4 Sided Aluminum Braid is as noted in the Spec Sheets? Also I know the 5740 has only been Sweep Tested to 1000mhz but if you extrapolate it out to 2200mhz [as is done on the spec sheet] the 5740 actually has better Loss Figures then the 5781.
So here are links to the Manufactures Spec Sheets; have a look and tell me what you guys think is the real advantage to paying the extra dough for the 5781 would have been? Spec Sheet CommScope 5781 or Spec Sheet CommScope 5740 [adobe format].
Peace - James/N8SBU
Posted 17 February 2003 - 03:53 PM
The most important parts of dealing with coaxial cabling for RF systems, specifically cable and satellite, are:
- good shielding - ingress in messes up your reception and leakage out angers the FCC
- good jacket without breaks - water and atmospheric contaminants eat the internals
- good fittings - badly designed and/or applied fittings will cause ingress and/or leakage and/or water and atmospheric contamination
- good cable run practice - no tight twists, bends, and definitely no kinks
We are no longer talking about analog systems where the slightest signal problems were immediately apparent on your screen. Digital error correction makes many slight problems invisible to the user, up to a point, at which you get "sparklies".
Using these two cables, with identical installation supplies and practices will not cause any errors you will notice without an oscilloscope and spectrum analyzer.
When purity of signal becomes important is when there is intent to distribute the signal massively which thus requires amplification. Amplifiers amplify everything within the target band that they don't filter out and that means noise as well. This is why you should use a 1 meter dish or better for a several hundred apartment MDU and you only need an eighteen incher for a single family house with four sets.
Remember, good materials and practices geared to the end result desired are all that is required to deliver service that you'll be happy with. Anything beyond that is strictly optional.
Proud Supporter of any initiative to bring High Definition adult programming to cable and satellite
Posted 18 February 2003 - 11:15 AM
Peace - James/N8SBU
"Armed and Curious"