It was a slow day at work (I'm a Firefighter) so I threw together this quick Excel sheet.
Some info about it, First, he is WANTING Two HDDVR's, Second, He has AAA, so I added the AAA Discount to DTV, couldn't find any such discount for the other providers. Third, in our area, we have DTV, DishNet, Comcast, and AT&T, so only they are listed. All promo's listed are for the Indianapolis Market, zip 46113.
I figured I would post this here, because it turns out over a two year period (life of contract) DTV is cheaper even after up front lease fees, plus he would get that 2nd. HDDVR that he can't get on U-Verse.
If even one person finds this useful besides him, I guess I didn't completely waste my time!