Welcome to DBSTalk
- Start new topics and reply to others
- Subscribe to topics and forums to get email updates
- Get your own profile page and make new friends
- Send personal messages to other members.
Recordings start late/end early
Posted 27 November 2007 - 06:55 PM
HR20-700 & Cavalry 750GB eSata HD
Samsung LN-S4692D 46" LCD
HR20-700 & Cavalry 750GB eSata HD
Philips 37PFL5322D 37" LCD
Posted 27 November 2007 - 08:35 PM
Just as a curiosity thing, has anyone run into this symptom with the R15? It would be interesting to find out if the R15 also has the same issue.
Posted 27 November 2007 - 09:32 PM
I just did an apples to apples test between a SD DirecTivo I have and the HR20. And definitely, the HR20 starts recording about 20-30 seconds later than the DirecTivo. Here are the details:
I set up the same SD program from the guide in both machines starting at 9:30 pm with no padding or anything. I let them record for about 5 minutes and then went to play them on my split screen TV set side by side. The Tivo based machine started recording right on time while the HR20 took at least 20 seconds to 30 seconds more before it started recording.
Same multiswitch feed
Same channel (SD)
For some reason, the HR20 takes longer to start recording.
It is not the networks, not different timing between the SD and the HD version of the same channel. It is the timing in the HR20.
I hope this helps the DirecTV engineers.
Thanks for performing a functional test that should have been done a year ago at D*. I have observed this issue for 12 months now, and it indicates bad engineering and poor oversight. If the hardware is overburdened, can we please have an upgrade in future HR generations?
Posted 28 November 2007 - 12:12 AM
It is also possible that the HR20 is wimpy in the CPU department.
Possible, but not likely. These boxes are full of DSPs, disc controllers, etc, all of which do DMA. Anyhow, 20-30 seconds is an eternity in CPU time.
I smell a deadly embrace between two threads, each waiting for the other to complete.
IMO, this issue ought to be triaged to the top of their bug list (if they have one)--right along with the bug that causes Dolby Digital to get mangled for 20 seconds after FF/RW/etc.
HR20-100, HR24NC-100, HR21-700
Samsung HLS5687WX 56" DLP
Onkyo TX-SR705 A/V receiver
Samsung Blue-Ray/DVD player
4-channel NTSC modulator
Posted 28 November 2007 - 01:05 AM
Thanks for goving me a chuckle before I sign off for the night.
Posted 28 November 2007 - 11:47 AM
Part of the problem with my HR20's is with their inabillity to keep the correct time. I have two HR20's and have tested them split screen, scheduled to record the same show. They never start at the same time. The clocks are never the same. Neither ever matches my atomic clocks or cell phones (which are right).
I think that there is another part of the problem.
Say they program the recordings to start exactly at the right time. Let's even assume that their internal clock is exactly right.
When the triger comes, the HR20's still need to take about a year to change channels and then start recording. Watch your HR20 when it begins recording a show and you will see this is exactly what happens.
Do that by hand and see how long it takes. 5-12 seconds?
So they will always be late by 5-12 seconds if they begin the processs of changing channels and starting a recording "on time".
So at least part of the solution has to be to start recordings a little early whenever possible. Maybe automatically pad a minute to the beginning if possible?
Still this does nothing to explain why they end early so consistently.
• A Simple Channels I Receive Solution • A Dramatically Faster User Interface
• Undocumented Tips & Tricks • HD DVR FAQ • Wish List Survey
• Installation FAQ • TiVo Users Survival Guide
Be a DBSTalk Club Member for $15 Support DBSTalk.com
Posted 03 December 2007 - 01:10 PM