Separate names with a comma.
Discussion in 'DIRECTV HD DVR/Receiver Discussion' started by harperhometheater, Oct 10, 2012.
Actually HDDVR's are $199.
So does buying a C31 involve the 24 month commitment? The SS site says "DIRECTV requires a 24 month (lease) commitment on all activated receivers", but this thing doesn't quack like a receiver in my eyes. If it adds the 24 months, my opinion would be to say heck with it and get a DVR instead. This thing should be treated like an AM21, not a receiver.
Windows Media Center extenders, like the Linksys DMA2100, were $400 each when they came out. $99 seems like a decent price point for what it does.
But they had 4 times the functionality, if the price was half what it is I would consider one, but not at 100.00, for that I will stick with my DVR's
I don't understand your point.
$99 (the price at SS) + $100 (the "at most" additional money it would cost for an HD DVR as quoted from my prior post) = $199.
So, for "at most" $100 more, I can have an HD DVR, with two of its own tuners and storage, hence, IMO, the C31 is priced way too high.
Doesn't matter - wahooq always will side with the provider. Perhaps his engagement...
Exactly. The Directv company stooges have been told to push this disaster called C31. It is a profit goldmine for Directv in that there is no tuner or hard drive in it and costs very little to produce. Read though the threads on DBS lately and these Directv company stooges swoop down on anybody who dares say anything negative about the C31. I think that Directv is presently the best TV service out there but they are not my god nor will I ever be their fanboy. It is simple arithmetic. Even at double the price a DVR with a tuner and hard drive is a far better deal for the customer. A couple of other things to think about. Directv makes a lot of profit off of PPV. It is in their interest to limit tuners and hard drive space so you will keep downloading movies. Also, pretty neat trick to charge you $6 a month for a box that has no ability of its own but simply rides on another box that you already pay a monthly fee on. I think you call that double dipping.
To people having a temper tantrum over the C31, like macfan: Maybe you need to realize the C31, like every other box isn't for everyone. It's an OPTION and no one is forcing it on you. Not everyone needs a tuner or DVR in every room.
How is it a disaster? It's basically the same thing as Dish's Joey...is that a disaster, too?
I'll agree that the C31 is priced too high when compared to a HD receiver or HD DVR, I think a $50 price point would have been better. I also agree that the $6/client fee is also to high when it would be charged for the 4th through 8th clients since only three clients can be active at a time to a HR34.
Where I'll disagree is with your C31 is a disaster statement. I replaced a couple HR24's that were in bedroom environments with C31's due to the C31's don't produce any noise. Even the quietest HD DVR will have some noise from it due to the cooling fan or hard drive noise, the C31 totally elimiates that. It's also more effecient from a power use standpoint, yea I know we're not talking big numbers here but every little bit helps.
Directv is not forcing the C31 on you yet but all you have to do is look at the receiver choices they are limiting new customers to and you can see where they are headed.
I just went to the DIRECTV web site and played new customer. I selected the HR34/Genie and while it gave me the option of the C31's it still listed all the other receivers as available, you just have to pay extra for them. So if you want something else you can still get it, just have to pay for it.
While agreeing its overpriced, but not necessarily with everything else you wrote, I don't think your claim above is so much of a "neat trick" by DIRECTV as it is an obvious necessity.
Since DIRECTV would be shooting themselves in the foot by destroying the monthly lease/mirror pricing structure for their current HD receivers and DVRs by the crush of HR34 customers with additional receivers trading in those additional boxes for C31s to save on the $6.00/mo. per box charge on their bills.
Don't forget about the energy savings associated with using one dvr and multiple clients, it may not be a huge amount for any normal home but we all benefit as a Nation.
You can still use other receivers if you would like as mentioned but new customers will probably be happy with the new "norm".
Perhaps I didn't write what I said clearly. I should have said look at the new customers offers. You kind of corrected it for me though as you wrote if you color outside of the lines of the new customer agreement it is going to cost you.
Please keep the thread friendly and let's not resort to name calling. I understand that some may not like the server/client setup and nobody is forcing that on you.
If you already have the Genie (HMC34), does adding a C31 extend your 2 year committment?
LOL, Scott, respectfully, please don't ever put me in the category of a normal technology customer. The norm, as you put it, would be my 90 year old mother. I sure hope I am way beyond that.
That's crazy how business works...you want more, you pay more. I guess everything should be free?
I think it's worth saying, RVU is the future direction for all of this. It's not proprietary information, it's just obvious. Just like DIRECTV first made SWM optional, then made it mandatory for new installs, and now has both a DVR and receiver that are SWM only, I think you can expect to see the same thing happen with RVU. And it's a good thing, in my opinion.
There will always be retailers who will sell (lease) you additional equipment designed for the DIYer or someone who wants to service an older installation. But moving forward RVU gives the vast majority of users exactly what they want:
-DVR features in every room in a small, quiet box
-5 tuners (the most common install now is HR24 + 3 H25 == 5 tuners)
-the possibility for a "no box" install (if Samsung ever approves the 2012 TVs)
-lower electric bills
I understand that high-end users like us won't be happy with 5 tuners. That's why you can get an HR24 through your choice of sources.
To characterize this as DIRECTV pushing something bad on us that we don't want... I just have to disagree.
And to be 100% clear that is my opinion and not that of any other entity I represent.
Since it appears the C31's will be leased I'd have to say yes it will.