1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Disappointing Charlie chat dish not leader HD

Discussion in 'General DISH™ Discussion' started by calikarim, Jan 13, 2004.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. calikarim

    calikarim Mentor

    Nov 11, 2003
    I am very disappointed in charlie and dish network. We are supposed to be leader in HD. No big marketing push for HD pvr 921. Direct Tv will have its out on time in 6 weeks. NOt enough 921's made give me a break. I was really disappointed to see Charlie respond to question on new HD channels, Bravo, Cinemax, and Stars, saying they are still in negotioation. Who is this programming VP who is always is negotiations? 6 months is what Charlie said for new channels. I am really thinking of switching to Voom . They will have 39 HD channels by next month. Dish is really loosing their edge. Even adelphia is strongly going after HD.
  2. Frank Z

    Frank Z Godfather

    Nov 15, 2002
    He did bring up a good point though regarding HD content. So much of what's out there is not true HD, instead it is upverted standard def. Personnaly I'd rather see more True-HD programming. I've watched a few movies on HDMovies and the PQ isn't that great compared to HDNet's progamming, or even the CBS-HD programming.
  3. wmayo

    wmayo Mentor

    Dec 1, 2002
    I have to agree with Calikarim. I believe in negotiating the best deal, but, not at the expense of becoming far behind in HD offerings.
    Actually, I think last night did it. I was one of Dish's first customers. As soon as Adelphia finalizes contract with CBS (it's already online in beta test), I'm pulling the plug on Dish. I'll be using Adelphia for HD locals mainly (minimum package) and VOOM for, let's see ... East and West HD generally for Showtime, Starz, The Movie Channel, Disc. HD, and coming in Feb. HBO, ESPN, Cinema 10, and about 10 other specialty channels.
    BTW - HDNet movies have been high PQ. The Music Man is just absolutely stunning. That is the only channel I'll miss (and that would be assuming it never arrives on VOOM).
    I have to admit, Dish is the SD leader. Meanwhile, I'll keep my 6000 - not totally burning my bridges.
  4. DonLandis

    DonLandis Hall Of Fame

    Dec 17, 2003
    Don't know where you heard they don't have enough 921's made to supply demand but all information has been plenty to fill the pipelines once they think the bugs are soon to be minimized. This 921 release is no different than other robust receivers from E*. One month of controlled release followed by software updates followed by filling the pipelines. MY only complaint is that _I_ didn't get one sooner but that is me being self centered for once. I do understand the system and see it following historical practice.

    Programming is a problem right now with Dish Network. The negotiation excuse has been used by DirecTv as they negotiated Showtime for 2.5 years! Now CE is using that excuse. At CES, I heard the same excuse. Is there an answer? If it is true that Networks like starz HD is purported to want more money than HBO and Showtime combined than CE is justified in holding out, same with DirecTV. VOOM gets it quicker because they have a more aggressive need and are charging their early adopters a huge sum per month as well. VOOM told me the starz channel HD will cost their subscribers $15 per month. Recall Discovery HD was at $8 on Dish and everyone complained. Why don't we hear the screaming from VOOM subscribers on their cost? Probably because the VOOM early adopters are all VOOM cheerleaders and the balance are indeed getting their money back. Let's wait until later summer to let the hype die off on VOOM and see how subscribers still like paying for the service. So, while I don't like waiting, I do respect that CE is trying to hold these programming providers to something the masses can afford. DirecTV too! If I can't stand it then I have the choice of paying the price through VOOM! Recall 2 years ago we didn't have any choices.
  5. wmayo

    wmayo Mentor

    Dec 1, 2002
    You're perspective is generally reasonable. I have to wonder, though, if Cinemax HD and The Movie Channel HD are asking as much as StarzHD. Is BravoHD so hot and high that it takes so many months and still no deal?
    As far as Starz at $15 - I would get East and West for that while cable and Dish, etc. charge $13 for just East. I can hack the $2 (though I admit there's no advantage when one has an HD-PVR).
    I admit, Dish could redeem itself in the longer haul, but they'd better really get going by, say, March 31 (VOOM deadline). I was really originally just "toying" with VOOM, but it's not impossible for my patience to run out with Dish, and ...
  6. Cyclone

    Cyclone Hall Of Fame/Supporter DBSTalk Gold Club

    Jul 1, 2002
    I think that there is a bandwidth crunch on 110 as far as HD is concerned. Charlie knows that Cinemax and Starz do not have nearly the subcribers as HBO and Showtime. If he devotes a transponder to them now, while they are not showing 100%, he might have to pass up on other HD channels such as TNT-HD that are soon to be unveiled.

    Don't forget that if he adds Cinemax-HD or StarZ-HD, that the package price for those likely won't go up a cent. At least by adding TNT, Bravo, or something else to the existing HD package, Charlie can pocket those procedes since he likely gets most of the $$$ from the HD package.
  7. Babnitoshi

    Babnitoshi New Member

    Jan 5, 2004
    What is the status of the other major networks' HD programming on Dish - ie., ABC and NBC?
  8. EchoDork

    EchoDork AllStar

    Jan 13, 2004
    As a general rule, Dish is interested in negotiating with any provider offering HD programming. As for networks, I think if another network approached Charlie with an offer and a reasonable price, he'd jump on it. When will that happen? Who knows.
  9. rcbridge

    rcbridge Godfather

    Oct 31, 2002
    He doesn't claim to be the leader in HD anymore, I guess that was last years theme,
    now it's the leader in BINGO!!!!! :lol:
  10. dbdsac

    dbdsac Legend

    Nov 17, 2003
    Frank Z-
    I completely agree with you. Give me true HD, not uprezzed SD!
  11. RAD

    RAD Well-Known Member

    Aug 5, 2002
    Does Dish have to pay extra for Starz-HD and Cinemax-HD, or TMC-HD for that fact. There was another post that I saw, after last month's disappointing chat, where someone said they called Starz and asked if they charge providers extra to carry the HD channel, the answer was no.
  12. cpdretired

    cpdretired AllStar/Supporter DBSTalk Gold Club

    Aug 25, 2003
    When you subscribe to any premium movie channel on C Band you receive the HD at no additional cost.
  13. clapple

    clapple Godfather

    Feb 11, 2003
    I agree the bandwith crunch is the real reason for no new HD; but I think Charlie would rather use it for locals.

    Like almost everyone here, I want more HD; but what will bring more revenue to Dish? Locals have the potential to bring in lots of new subs. More HD would only please a relatively small number of existing subs, with little increased revenue.

    Looks like an simple business decision, to me.
  14. Stosh

    Stosh Godfather

    Dec 16, 2003
    >I was really disappointed to see Charlie respond to question on
    >new HD channels, Bravo, Cinemax, and Stars, saying they are
    >still in negotioation.

    I am a new member to this forum, and I am disappointed because all I seem to read here is whining and complaining. Are you really that interested in getting more HD channels that don't show HD programming? Face it - ESPN HD is almost a complete waste of time, because virtually all they show is distorted standard definition programming. If that is what you want, indeed, please do subscribe to VOOM - you'll be happy there, as you watch non-HD programming (which is about all they offer) on Bravo, Cinemax, and STARZ HD channels.
  15. sampatterson

    sampatterson Icon/Supporter DBSTalk Gold Club

    Aug 27, 2002
    I would rather have an upconvert channel more than the SD overcompressed channel and I am willing to pay for it. The HD upconverts are much better picture quality.
  16. Chris Walker

    Chris Walker Guest

    Chaz needs to add some new channels to 100 and 150 more than he needs to add more HD. I mean how can he justify a price increase on 150 and Everything package when nothing has been added? Charlie and E* are obsessed with adding tons of locals and interactive games, and have ignored everything else lately. What gives?
  17. lesmoss

    lesmoss AllStar

    Dec 12, 2003
    Yes, ESPN-HD is better than the SD channel on Dish, but it is no better than my analog cable. Given the choice of 3 sources for the golf tournament last weekend, I watched it on analog cable, primarily because the quality of the picture was the same as HD and I prefer the "Natural Wide" expansion provided by my Pioneer TV to the simple stretch done by ESPN-HD.

    Until they provide more HD content, Charlie should ditch it in favor of something with full time HD content.

  18. Five Hole

    Five Hole Legend

    Jun 23, 2002
    I believe I heard Charlie say on the CC that Dish asked ABC and NBC to do something similar to CBS-HD but the networks refused.
  19. dbdsac

    dbdsac Legend

    Nov 17, 2003
    That is what I said in my post above...give me TRUE HD, not uprezzed SD.

    In regards to ESPN-HD, granted most of their programming is unimpressive uprezzed SD, which I do not watch, but their live HD broadcast of professional sports is outstanding to watch! WOW!! To me, these broadcasts alone are worth the $10/month for the HD package. In addition, ESPN is building a brand new, state-of-the-art HD studio for future broadcasts. ESPN gets it and they are committed ($$$$) to the inevitable future of HD...just wait :)
  20. So I have this all correct, you are saying DirecTV will have its product out in 6 weeks and on time?

    How would you know that unless you have discovered some way to visit the future?

    VOOM is a programmer built out of chewing gum a bailing wire. Wall Street is very wary of VOOM.

    I couldn't wait for DirecTV, even IF they deliver on the goods in six weeks.

    I guess we'll find out in six weeks, of course we expect a full report back from you as I know your system will be installed, up and running at your house on that six week time schedule!

    Yankee born Southern bred
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page