You weren't double billed .. You were being charged for Sunday Ticket all along. You were getting Premier for free. You were still getting premier for free when you chose to cancel it. We don't care? :scratchin You should try and get DIRECTV to credit your account because of this confusion. They might just do that .. ask for a one time credit. But it seems like you're ready to move on ... You do realize that you had both NFL Sunday Ticket (2010) and virtually every channel DIRECTV offers for 5 months .. at pretty much the same cost as the CHOICE XTRA package. That's one heck of a deal and even if you were to eat the additional $30-35 because of the billing confusion you still have made out like a bandit. I still think you have a shot at a one time credit that will put you on par with what you thought you were getting in the first place ..