1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

from a new subscriber..................

Discussion in 'DIRECTV General Discussion' started by flybynyte, Aug 14, 2012.

  1. flybynyte

    flybynyte Cool Member

    Aug 8, 2012
    i guess (hate to use "assume" for the obvious reasons :goofygrin) it may come down to personal preference, but, just wondered about the $6/mo protection plan. do you believe it is really worth it? it seems much of the stuff is covered just by becoming a subscriber to directv, isn't it?

    would like to read comments. thanks
  2. Xsabresx

    Xsabresx Icon

    Oct 8, 2007
    You are going to get two very different opinions on this. Some feel $6/mo is worth it for peace of mind while others find it a completed waste of $72/yr.

    For me it's worth it. It's a tiny amount I dont ever think about and I have peace of mind.
  3. flybynyte

    flybynyte Cool Member

    Aug 8, 2012
    i think if my set-up involved as much equipment as yours, it might make sense. i really expected a comment such as yours---as it makes perfect sense. i have heard numerous "electronic" wizards comment on protection plans. just thot i would see what i could stir up. thanks for taking time to reply.
  4. dpeters11

    dpeters11 Hall Of Fame

    May 30, 2007
    For a lot of people, it probably doesn't make a lot of sense. If you have a receiver go bad, you still get a new one, but you will have a $20 shipping fee (though it's not unheard of for that to be waived.) If you live in an area with lots of very strong winds and have to have your dish aligned a lot, it also might make sense. But most don't have issues like that.

    I think where it makes the most sense is for those that have owned boxes. After making the investment to get boxes that aren't leased, you'd want to get owned replacements if there was an issue.
  5. mjwagner

    mjwagner Icon

    Oct 8, 2005
    Been a DirecTV subscriber for a LONG time, since before they even had anything like a protection plan. I have never had the PP and have never had a problem getting DirecTV to send someone to the house to fix things or to get defective equipment replaced free of charge (remember, with rare exception, it is all leased so you don't even really own it). It has happened very rarely but I have never had to pay for a service call. This is really one of those personal preference issues. Some people just "feel better" being covered by a PP. From a purely economic perspective these types of things are rarely worth the money. But, that is JMHO and YMMV.
  6. sonofcool

    sonofcool Legend

    Dec 23, 2007
    I have it and plan to keep it. For me, even if it saves 30 minutes of conversation every other year its worth it. I know others feel its expensive and that is fine. I'm happy we have the choice :)
  7. fratwell

    fratwell Legend

    Jul 2, 2005
    I have had the PP for over 5 years and just had a great service request to correct a 771 Searching error. I had the old side car and the Northeast area had recent 3 day downpours. Tech discovered water in the LNB and replaced the entire Dish with the 3LB slimline and cabled everything new.

    Signals for 99c and 103c in the mid-90's now with the new 3LNB slimline and cabling. Cost with the PP? Nothing.
  8. trh

    trh This Space for Sale

    Nov 2, 2007
    NE FL
    I've never had it. Had two times since 1998 when techs had to make service calls (diagnosis/replace multi-switch and dish realignment). Both times DirecTV, said "you're such a loyal customer, we'll waive the service call." I've also replaced a number of boxes, usually $19.95 plus tax for shipping, but they have even waived that a few times.
  9. Shades228

    Shades228 DaBears

    Mar 18, 2008
    Like all insurance it boils down to if you want to pay in advance for something and never have to worry about it or are you always in a financial sound place where you could afford to replace receivers if they were damaged by lightening (this is the most expensive situation) and not covered under home owners insurance, protection plan covers lightening damage but not other types of damage, is the main question.

    If you have owned equipment it's a different story.
  10. HarleyD

    HarleyD Hall Of Fame

    Aug 31, 2006
    It's a form of gambling really, as is all insurance. If you don't have it you're betting that you will never incur an expense greater that the cost of the protection plan.

    DirecTV is betting that you will pay them more for the plan then it will cost them to cover you for any failures under your coverage.

    Bear in mind, that if DirecTV wasn't coming out ahead they wouldn't be doing it.

    But also bear in mind that it costs them less to make good on the plan than it will cost you to cover those costs out of your pocket without the protection plan.

    I used to work for a manufacturer and our extended warranties were some of the biggest profit centers in the company, but at the ridiculous prices we charged for parts and service out of warranty the customers were better off being covered. The replacement parts were dirt cheap for us sine we either manufactured them ourselves or purchased them in bulk and the labor was being supplied by people we were already employing and paying whether they were repairing a unit or not.

    The whole thing is a little twisted. Imagine this exchange...

    Prospective Insurance Buyer: "What is Life Insurance?"
    Insurance Agent: "That's where we bet that you will pay us more in premiums over the course of your lifetime than the policy will pay out upon your death."
    Prospective Insurance Buyer: "What if I die young?"
    Insurance Agent:"YOU WIN!"
  11. Shades228

    Shades228 DaBears

    Mar 18, 2008

    Actually NEW is betting it since they are the company that does the work and pays for the claims. DIRECTV gets the confidence of knowing people will have issues fixxed and paid for not out of it's own pocket and gets a compensation in some form for signing people up.
  12. carl6

    carl6 Moderator Staff Member DBSTalk Club

    Nov 15, 2005
    Seattle, WA
    There are many things that can go wrong in a satellite system. If you are comfortable doing some basic troubleshooting/fault isolation (with help from these forums), you can typically figure out what the problem is. Next question becomes fixing it. If your dish goes out of alignment, you'll need to be able to get to it, then make precise adjustments to optimize the signal. If a coax or connector goes bad, you'll have to replace it. Etc. If you are comfortable with those kinds of tasks, then you don't need the protection plan. Otherwise, it is probably worth it.
  13. JimAtTheRez

    JimAtTheRez Legend

    May 9, 2008
    For me, yes.
  14. inf0z

    inf0z Legend

    Oct 15, 2011
    This depends on a number of factors.
    1. How many receivers you have. The more you have the more you may have to replace down the road.
    2. How good you are at fixing things yourself, some people don't like to do a lot of troubleshooting and prefer a tech to come out.
    3. Weather in your area. Heavy snow fall, heavy ice buildup, and heavy winds will all cause heavier wear and tear on the exterior portions of your installation increasing your chances of needing a service call.

    Also keep in mind that most customers can add the service plus protection plan at any time which includes the current service call or equipment replacement you are calling about at no charge, this depends on your account status though.
  15. lipcrkr

    lipcrkr Legend

    Apr 27, 2012
    I had it free for the first month (i started this May) but decided not to continue. I only have one HD receiver, my install went well including reinforced wire from my home to the Dish, i have no obstructions, and i live near the Beach in LA., so really no weather to worry about. So i'm happy to keep my $6.
  16. flybynyte

    flybynyte Cool Member

    Aug 8, 2012
    thanks for the different point of views. appreciate it. i will make final decision at time of installation.
  17. fleckrj

    fleckrj Icon

    Sep 4, 2009
    Cary, NC
    I have had DirecTV since 1999 and have never had the protection plan. During that time, I have had defective boxes replaced three times and had one service call (not counting the call to switch from SD to HD). DirecTV waived the fees each time. For the service call, which was to replace my LNB-5 with a LNB-3 and realign the dish, the DirecTV technician would not go on the roof to do the work. He did leave the LNB-3 with me (for which I was not charged), but I had to hire an independant contractor to do the work. That cost me about $98, but that is all that I have paid for service-related things in 13 years. Even if I had paid the $6 per month, DirecTV technicians will not go on my roof (and there is no other way to get LOS on my property), so I will always end up paying an independant contractor for dish alignments or LNB replacements.

    I have one HR21, one H21, one H23, one H24, a SWiM-8 and a Slimline-3. I do all of the interior wiring myself, though, so I only need service if the box, dish, or LNB are bad or if the initial connection at the LNB fails. Once the four wires from the LNB reach my attic, I take care of everything downstream and have never had a problem. If the SWiM-8 fails, I will be stuck with the cost of that replacement, too, but unless it fails more than once every two years (which is very highly unlikely), I would still come out ahead by not having the service plan.

    If you are not comfortable diagnosing and fixing problems yourself, then I would say that the $6 per month is worth it, but for me, it is not.
  18. wingrider01

    wingrider01 Hall Of Fame

    Sep 9, 2005
    Couple of other things

    - if you own your equipment it is pretty much a requirement to make sure you keep it owned.

    - the most important, my billiable time is worth a lot more then 6 bucks a month for me to diagnose and try and fix and issue, one call, walk through the 5 or 10 minutes of questions, then they dispatch or send the device.

    - cost is next to nothing, spend more on a drink ina single night then I do on the PP

    Bottom line - if someone feels it is worth it, then it is, if they don't then it is not - it is a personal decision

Share This Page