I have the same four choices available to me + of course OTA. They are all available to me as YES is not a manditory selection criteria anymore. DVRs are a must have though. I keep hearing bad things about the FIOS and CableCo DVRs from customers where I work. DirecTv has finally gotten it's HR20 good to go and Dshnetworks DVR is OK too. Or a Tivo HD OTA box excluding the subscription charge. Bottom line is Fios may be cheaper but I would need 5 tuners worth of DVR to equal what I have and a Digital Video Recorder (DVR) at $12.99/month per dual-tuner HD/DVR box will that really be cheaper or higher? or to feed more than one room a Multi-Room DVR is $19.99/month. So I would need at least 3 HD Dual tuner DVR at $12.99 per. Since they don't offer a cheaper SD Dual tuner box they'll need to be dual tuner HD DVRs so that add $38.96 a month to the price. Now from that Fee we take out the $6 Rental fee and the $10 mirroring fee I'm paying now and then we have a true comparison in my case. BTW I did a quick check and it looks like DIsh has more HD for now. DirecTv may be the highest in the semi-near future. Depends on how their satellite launches go.