Leaving DTV after 21 years

Discussion in 'DIRECTV General Discussion' started by Taxi77, Nov 23, 2016.

  1. trh

    trh This Space for Sale

    Nov 2, 2007
    NE FL
    Besides, I've used an X1.

    Compared to my HR44, C41 mini and HR24s, it is faster.
  2. thyname

    thyname Member

    May 9, 2015
    United States
    Another indicator (hands on experience) pointing to really antiquated Genie line. What I have said before. But nobody listens to me. You don't know how bad Genie is until you try something else. I have TiVo Bolt+

    Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
    1 person likes this.
  3. wilbur_the_goose

    wilbur_the_goose Hall Of Fame

    Aug 16, 2006
    D* is still asking for their ancient HR20's to be returned (at least they did for me), which implies they're "refurbishing" and reusing them.

    IMHO, the issue with not being able to request current equipment may end up killing D* for me.
  4. peds48

    peds48 Genius.

    Jan 10, 2008
    good luck to them eating DIGITAL breadcrumbs.....

    I never questioned his decision for leaving DIRECTV. I only raised the point that is not a fair comparison of older DIRECTV equipment and latest and greatest from the other company. The TS could have said that he left DIRECTV due to his crappy DIRECTV equipment without the need of comparison.

    no one is questioned those points, at least not me!

    Understood, I am not saying he did anything wrong by leaving DIRECTV. You are taking my words out of context, big time. Please stop.

    I appreciate ANY post.

    Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
  5. peds48

    peds48 Genius.

    Jan 10, 2008
    Not true, he can compare his experience of the services, but is not a fair comparison of cable latest and greatest and DIRECTV older hardware

    again, that is part of the experience, IOW, how satisfied are with the service, etc....

    Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
  6. Billzebub

    Billzebub Godfather

    Jan 1, 2007
    Pittsburgh, PA
    I am in the unique position of having DIRECTV at home and XFINITY at my apartment in Harrisburg. Overall I prefer DIRECTV but the gap is a lot closer that it was a few years ago.
    I have an HR54, an HR24 and an HR21 at home and an X1 in Harrisburg.
    There are a few more pluses for Comcast. Their out of home solution is far superior to the mobile DVR DIRECTV uses. Better picture quality, ability to view downloaded programs without an internet connection and, most importantly it works, all the time, while I can rarely use the DIRECTV mobile DVR for anything other than streaming on demand, which I acan do with apps from the various programmers without the DIRECTV app. Also, the customer service, while still not great, is greatly improved from the old days. DIRECTV is still better, but XFINITY is getting better while DIRECTV is going down hill. The gap is most definitely closing. Also, with XFINITY you get the local sub channels without an antenna and AM21 or the need to program in multiple locations because DIRECTV isn't interested in an over the air solution.
    On the other hand, as others have mentioned the picture, while not as bad as soon would have you think, is inferior to DIRECTV. Also, again as mentioned by others, the lack of premium channels in HD is a big negative. I know you can watch on demand, but sometimes you just want to watch what is on. Sunday ticket is still a plus for DIRECTV, but the value is getting lessened for me by the number of over the air games each week. The truth is, I mostly watch the red zone channel, which is available by itself from XFINITY. I usually get Sunday Ticket for free and I don't think I would pay for it.
    Two additional advantages for DIRECTV in my eyes are:
    1. Channel placement - Here in Pittsburgh CBS is on channel 2 whether it's in HD, SD or over the air. On my X1 I need to figure out what Channel the locals are on. Very confusing. They do have a setting where the box will automatically tune to the HD channel if you select the ad channel, but even this work around is clunky at best.
    2. I may be in the minority, but I'm a fan of the audience network and some of the foreign programming it has shown. Underbelly and the original rake from Australia come to mind, along with the last seasons of Friday Night Lights and Damages along with Full Circle.

    I guess my point is, while I still prefer DIRECTV the lead is nowhere close to what it used to be. While their reasons may be self-serving (let's face it, all business decisions, by definition, are), they have definitely improved in quality and customer service. DIRECTV, on the other hand, has become a bit stagnant and much less customer friendly. I am hoping the next generation of equipment will move towards a client server system with more recording channels available and a more elegant 4K solution, but I expect to be disappointed.
    1 person likes this.
  7. ejbvt

    ejbvt AllStar

    Aug 14, 2011
    Your two reasons are some of my biggest issues with cable. Why are the channels so incoherently random on the X1 system? It makes zero sense. Audience is a great channel, lots of cool programming, not on cable. The HD lineup on cable here is laughable, too, compared to Directv. The crappy Directv client situation needs to be addressed. My parents have X1 and have a second box in another room from the main TV. There have been zero connectivity issues with that unit, which is I believe is a client based system. They were Dish people for my mom to have CW until they got a local CW. They had the Superstation Pack and it gave them 3 CW options. Once they got a CW, Dish took away those channels and added the local CW. They don't care about sports or even HD (they have even less HD, if that is possible) so bundling with X1 works for them. It's been a year for them, and the channel numbers still confuse them to this day. "I told it go to channel 3. Now it's up on channel 700 something and I can't find channel X."

    But it was great the other day when the power went out, and then came back on and Comcast was out for like 3 hours longer while I was watching Directv, with heavy wet snow falling, with no signal problems.
  8. JosephB

    JosephB Icon

    Nov 14, 2005
    Birmingham, AL
    Because cable isn't a single national system, and is the result of 40 years of growth, consolidation, and extremely slow forward progress combined with incredibly long reaching backwards compatibility and government-imposed standards developed by third parties.

    Channel placement is random because there used to be thousands of cable companies. The local cable company was just that...local. Over time they've consolidated into the Charters and Comcasts of the world, but through that consolidation the systems are still physically separate, and there is no real reason to standardize. Who cares if TNT or CNN is on channel 18 in Pittsburgh but channel 36 in Atlanta? Same thing kind of goes for the locals, too. Yeah, they're not where they are over the air, but in the long run what does it matter..most people aren't bouncing between OTA and cable, so once they know where a given network is, that's where it's at.

    Cable is also very, very slow to change, and is very old. DirecTV has been around maybe half as long as cable, so there's a lot of legacy baggage cable has to deal with in terms of bad decisions and just old technology. Plus, DirecTV has been much more willing to rip off bandaids when necessary and push changes when it makes sense. Plus, DirecTV controls 100% of their stack. Cable companies don't control their systems, Arris and Cisco do. Plus, they have to adhere to standards that they may not have any input to, and provide compatibility with 3rd party hardware like TiVos, old hardware like older TiVos and older TVs, and more. From a pure service perspective satellite and cable and telco are the same (multi-channel linear video programming) but from a technology and implementation details, you might as well be comparing cars with microwave ovens.
  9. APB101

    APB101 Icon

    Sep 1, 2010
    My brother is under contract (equipment upgrade) with DirecTV until March 2017.

    He is considering leaving for Comcast. He wants Red Zone Channel and couldn't get it with DirecTV unless he signed up for NFL Sunday Ticket. (He doesn't want to spend the money to subscribe.)

    If he does it, bundling television and Internet will be a help for overall costs.

    In this area, Detroit, Michigan, 75Mbps is the Performance package. I think I came across a report that some areas' 75Mbps will move up to 100Mbps.

    Can I ask you your television market, Taxi77?
  10. Taxi77

    Taxi77 Cool Member

    Jan 25, 2008
    Northern Virginia. So my 150 is supposed to move to 200 soon. And as far as everyone talking about channel numbers, they will be learned, not an issue for me. For now, I just tell the remote "Watch Fox News" and it goes there until I learn all of the numbers that I am interested in knowing. It's been 4 weeks now and, knock on wood, no problems.
  11. Ed Campbell

    Ed Campbell Hall Of Fame

    Feb 17, 2006
    Up to a week ago I was ready to do the same. Can't get a small enough and affordable package for what I watch nowadays. Been with D* 22 years.

    Xfinity looked to be a sound technical choice - especially with fibre to the house which goes back to TCI just before Comcast bought them. Then, wandering through Xfinity forums, I found folks from Pittsburgh to the Rockies getting upset over a recent decision to begin downrezzing HD feeds to 720P.

    Enough to remove consideration. If they realize how dumb that is and turn it around, I'll give 'em a try. But, for now, everything I see - including direct quotes from named CSRs - says this is a nationwide rollout.
  12. JeffBowser

    JeffBowser blah blah blah

    Dec 21, 2006
    Not only downgrading the signal to 720p, but also compressing the ever-loving tar out of it. I miss DirecTV for three things - better picture, better guide and channel arrangement, and better trick-play. Comcast is better or equal in all else, especially cost.
  13. mcl77

    mcl77 AllStar

    Nov 25, 2008
    Im happy to say Ill be able to watch hdtv tonite with a downpour going on. Wasn't able to do that with directTV.
    Another plus to ps vue
  14. mcl77

    mcl77 AllStar

    Nov 25, 2008
    How is the channel arrangement for Comcast???
    I love how they have it on ps vue. No numbers, they just go by alphabetical on the top. Time on the left.
  15. JeffBowser

    JeffBowser blah blah blah

    Dec 21, 2006
    Just like Ed said. Seemingly random. DirecTV had an excellent and logical arrangement.
  16. jfalkingham

    jfalkingham Godfather

    Dec 6, 2005
    the only way I contact them is via chat and twitter and responses have been snappy.

    I'm contemplating coming back to DTV after I left when no HD TiVo was out. Moved to Comcast to keep the TiVo love going, but they recently moved from gracenote to rovi for guide data and it's now a pile of junk and moved their support way offshore. Pitiful fall from grace.
  17. BarkingGhost

    BarkingGhost Legend

    Dec 29, 2007
    NE Atlanta...
    I have had my equipment changed out three times in the 15 years that I have been with DirecTV and they have always installed the OLDEST equipment in their available inventory. Feeling like a bottom of the barrel customer experience in this regard makes your point as moot as ten month old donuts.
  18. peds48

    peds48 Genius.

    Jan 10, 2008
    you are right on your comparison, as you are comparing the experience and not the equipment. Your experience with DIRECTV has been a poor one.
    Supramom2000 likes this.

Share This Page

spam firewall