Who were YOUR favorites tonight?
Aside from the fact that I'd switch Phillip and Elise... we're in total agreement.Drew2k said:To me Hollie won the night, with Elise and Jessica tied for second. Phillip was in the middle of the pack with Skylar and Joshua. And Colton was at the bottom. Alone. His performances seemed off-key and flat.
If fans voted based solely on tonight's performances, they should put Colton in the bottom three but it's a toss-up who will be with him.
It wasn't stage presence... it was her giving herself to the song.Steve said:I'm glad they finally cut Hollie a break. I don't think her stage presence was markedly different than last week's, but I guess they decided they beat that horse to death and decided to pick on Elise instead, after her second song.
It was indeed her strongest night, but I thought Hollie sorta won the night for her comeback with "Rolling In The Deep."Steve said:I actually thought Skylar won the night. She delivered on both those songs, IMHO. I know she's not going to win it all, but this was her strongest night on Idol so far, IMHO.
I've heard better performances of the song...Steve said:I'm a fan of Joshua's, but I didn't think he killed the Sam Cooke song at all, in spite of their praise. Overall, I thought it was a bad night for him, and I wouldn't be shocked if he goes home this week.
Sadly, he probably does...Doug Brott said:Colton better have a lot of 12 yr olds in his corner this week.
To each their own...Maruuk said:Elise with Let's Get it On was very uncomfortable trying to sell a Black-genre sex song. Seemed forced and embarrassing. Not sexy at all. She can't sell sexy. Neither the looks nor the skills. Her first tune was just ok.
I find that very offensive.Maruuk said:
Seriously? Body of a truck driver after too much truck stop food, a face like Howdy Doody. Yikes. I mean, Howdy was kinda cute, but...
I'm sure Elise is a really nice person. But trying to seduce us like some kind of hot vamp last night? I'd be more receptive to Stevie Nicks. Wait, no I wouldn't. Maybe Jimmy...at least he cuts down on the Krispy Kremes.
I voted for Jessica, Joshua and Phillip last night.Maruuk said: