First of all, thanks everyone for the pics and help so far.
Next, the reflector. Maybe it's just perspective, but the web pics look a bit more "square" than my dish. However, when I got on my ladder, I noticed that at least the top edge of my dish is straighter than I thought it was. The bottom edge looks rounder/more oval. Looking from the ground up, the whole dish looks more oval than the web pics, but it does measure the same as the AT9 specs on the Solid Signal website. The dish has a sticker with the work "Andrew" on it.
The secondary LNBs look like they could be the same, but the main LNB module definitely has a different style.
Fourth tech visit set up for Saturday (is there a record for most number of tech visits before system is stable?) so we'll see what happens then.