Dish has been successful moving flawed PVRs to their subscribers. DirecTV should be able to at least duplicate that success with the well-regarded and stable Tivo platform. The price at $5.00 a month is not too bad, especially in the light of two-tuner recording. You'd pay $5.00 for a second receiver anyway, but here you get PVR features. Of course you lose the ability to actually watch two programs at the same time, or have receivers in two different rooms, but I think it's still a compelling offer.