[Mark Lamutt]

Alrighty, so what'd you think? I loved the "Christmas Star" decimating London with the beam weapons shooting from the points of the star. And I thought the alien villain was really cool.

But, that said, while I thought it was a good epsiode, for me it didn't have the excitement factor that the Christmas epsiode last year had. It was a nice bridge epsiode between companions, and you could really see the sense of loss in the Doctor's eyes everytime he thought of Rose.

Who knew you could have a car chase with the Tardis?

 

[Mark Holtz]

The definate wow factor was the TARDIS flying down the thoroughfare trying to rescue Donna. Some of it was a little cliche, though. Still, we were provided a explanation as to how Donna got into the TARDIS. Still, I found Catherine Tate to be a tad annoyng and her character was written as "dense".