Fontano said:
Yes, they probably could have a found a way.
And honestly, IMHO. If it would have been Chris Columbus for all of them, I would have been very disappointed. While I liked the first movie, I really didn't like the second one.
The 3rd, it's style just wouldn't have worked for the 4th.
And I think the way the 5th movie went is perfect for the remainder of the series.
It's a good debate though.
It is a good debate. I think that on their own, each of the movies has been very good. But I think if they had one director through 7 movies, the overall experience would have been better. At some point, all 7 movies will be done, and to some extent they'll be looked at as one "project", and the different directors for the different movies take away from the overall "project".
Personally, I'm actually partial to Alfonso Cuaron's interpretation & style. I know these are "kids" books, but it really is, in many ways, a dark story, and I liked what Cuaron did with it.
That said, I do agree with you that movie 5 was very good and if the final movies match up to that, they'll be very good as well.
My wife is not a reader, and has not read any of the books. She's seen all 5 movies, but only to humor me! OOTP is the only movie that she actually enjoyed, which bodes well for the last few movies, IMO.