stangoldsmith said:
So - I live in an urban area with lots of HD channels that I can get just using my antenna. So if I understand correctly I can record them with my Dish HD receiver DVR (but without channel information on the DVR itself)?
If you don't pay Dish for local channels, Dish won't send your receiver ANY guide data for local channels, whether they are from the sat or from the OTA antenna. You can still record OTA locals on the HD-DVR, but you'll have no guide data and will have to set up your recordings manually. Meaning, instead of "record CSI:Miami" you'll have to tell your DVR "record channel 5 from 7pm to 8pm".
If you pay the extra $5 for locals, Dish will send you guide data, and you can set up 2 different DMA's guide (based on zip code), so if you're in between two cities, and can get both signals, you can get guide data for both.
And this is something that the person who is installing the satellite system in my house would know how to set up? Or should I ask the retailer that I order from on the phone?
How much extra should I pay the person (is it cash? "off the books"?) who is setting it up to fix up the local channels via antenna and do I need to go buy anything from Radioshack before he comes over?
Dish themselves, and Dish's internal techs, do not install OTA antennas as a rule. If you had one already installed, and the coax running to your receiver location, they would connect the coax to the receiver, but setting up and using the OTA functions is not supported by techs (it's easy to do, but not part of their job).
Many retailers do other things besides just Dish sales/installations, and will offer OTA antenna installations. Not all will. You'll have to call around and find out who does what and what they charge. OTA signals arrive differently at each house, so what works well for you may not work well for your neighbor across the street. Thus, price could vary far too much for anyone here to say for sure. I would say expect to pay $100 and up.
Why would I ever want to pay for local channels if I can get them free this way?
If you just want to WATCH OTA, all you need to do is plug the antenna into your ATSC-tuner-equipped TV and watch.
Many, many folks don't want an OTA antenna on their house, or go through the hassle of getting one installed, and want their locals via the dish. Many people can't have an OTA installed because of their landlord, etc, or it won't work because of local signal conditions.
Also, paying for locals gives you the ability to integrate those signals into your DVR, for guide data and recording.
Also if service calls cost money, the DVR costs additional money and other things cost extra money per month why is it better than cable? If it is that is.
Nothing worth having is free. Satellite TV is usually cheaper than cable, sometimes considerably so, WHEN YOU COMPARE EQUIVALENT SERVICES. If you have basic cable, and you want satellite with an HD-DVR and HD movie channels, of course you're going to pay more with sat, because you're GETTING a lot more. Still, satellite is not for everyone. IMO, sat delivers the most TV, the best DVR experience, and several other features that would make it "worth it" at double the price. The fact that it costs me less than what similar-but-lesser service from Comcast would charge me is only icing on the cake. YMMV.
As mentioned, assuming you have your system installed well, satellite TV is very, very reliable. Aside from a handful of <10 second interruptions during huge storm wind gusts, I've not lost satellite signal over the last 10 years except when I also lose power. Can't fault DirecTV for that.
My Comcat cable modem, on the other hand, and the Comcast TV service that some of my neighbors have, seems to go down all the time, and during storms, can be out for days at a time.
So, I have no trouble finding value in satellite for ME. Again, YMMV, and only you can decide if it is the best option for you.