DBSTalk Forum banner

Quality level of the new Tivo DVR?

  • Absolutely perfect. No bugs, no issues, no dislikes

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Okay. No bugs, no issues, but some features will need tweaking

    Votes: 11 14.5%
  • Fair. Some non-critical bugs, glitches, or features not up to par

    Votes: 26 34.2%
  • Bad. Nearly non-functional. More headaches than cheers

    Votes: 39 51.3%
1 - 20 of 40 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
12,607 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Lots of polls popping up around the Tivo announcement, so I thought I would start another one ....

We've all had our complaints about the bug/quality level of the non-Tivo DVRs, so what level of issues do you expect with the next generation DirecTiVo?
 

· Dry as a bone
Joined
·
12,321 Posts
We've also all had our complaints about the bug/quality level of tivo DVR's (depending how long you've been around).

And for the record, I haven't had any complaints about the quality level of non-tivo DVR's.
 

· Icon
Joined
·
578 Posts
spartanstew said:
We've also all had our complaints about the bug/quality level of tivo DVR's (depending how long you've been around).

And for the record, I haven't had any complaints about the quality level of non-tivo DVR's.
No complaints for me as well. My HR20 and new HR21 have been solid.

Since the TIVO will be a brand new software (and possibly hardware) solution, I would guess somewhere between bad and fair to start, with vast improvements coming quickly.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
4,296 Posts
You forgot a 5th choice in the Poll...

5. Checking any answer in this poll is dumb!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
8,035 Posts
Dude, do you have a death wish? The Tivohadists are going to hunt you down now. :lol: You've just become more hated than Salmon Rushdie. Better check your back seat the next time you get in your car, crazies are...unpredictable.
 

· Icon
Joined
·
578 Posts
RobertE said:
Dude, do you have a death wish? The Tivohadists are going to hunt you down now. :lol: You've just become more hated than Salmon Rushdie. Better check your back seat the next time you get in your car, crazies are...unpredictable.
:lol:

Now that's funny - I don't care who you are...
 

· Icon
Joined
·
927 Posts
LarryFlowers said:
You forgot a 5th choice in the Poll...

5. Checking any answer in this poll is dumb!
You keep showing up in every TiVo speculation thread, complaining that it's speculation.

Do you not understand the concept of a discussion forum? :confused:

If you want news, ignore the threads and leave the discussion to those that want to talk...
 

· Godfather
Joined
·
269 Posts
The first two choices are too high a standard for any box from any manufacture, ever.

Which of the last two will totally depend on whether it turns out to be based on an existing TiVo hardware box, like the TiVo HD XL DVR, or if like with the Comcast example they are forced to develop it as a software option on existing DirecTV hardware. Almost certainly they will have more serious problems if they do the latter. Also, it depends on when the release. They haven't even starting developing this yet but have promised an '09 delivery. If there is pressure to stick to that it's pretty likely there will be at least one or more serious bugs at launch. Hopefully not as bad as the early days of the HR20 in 2006, but still worse than it should be...
 

· Hall Of Fame
Joined
·
4,922 Posts
Citivas said:
The first two choices are too high a standard for any box from any manufacture, ever.

Which of the last two will totally depend on whether it turns out to be based on an existing TiVo hardware box, like the TiVo HD XL DVR, or if like with the Comcast example they are forced to develop it as a software option on existing DirecTV hardware. Almost certainly they will have more serious problems if they do the latter. Also, it depends on when the release. They haven't even starting developing this yet but have promised an '09 delivery. If there is pressure to stick to that it's pretty likely there will be at least one or more serious bugs at launch. Hopefully not as bad as the early days of the HR20 in 2006, but still worse than it should be...
Agreed. Also depends on how much neutering DirecTv makes them do.
 

· Hall Of Fame
Joined
·
6,417 Posts
Your poll,[ ...Mod edit: redacted comment...] no good choices. When D* announces something new 12 months down the road, I've learned over the years not to hold my breath. It may never happen. If and when a Tivo arrives it would have to have features the HR's don't or I wouldn't even consider it.
 

· Icon
Joined
·
589 Posts
Redlinetire said:
You keep showing up in every TiVo speculation thread, complaining that it's speculation.

Do you not understand the concept of a discussion forum? :confused:

If you want news, ignore the threads and leave the discussion to those that want to talk...
I thinkg discussion is fine but i think its a little early but it doesnt bother me. But i love my D*DVR, I have used tivo before and personally i hate tivo the UI is like using my kids leapfrog leapster.
 

· Icon
Joined
·
655 Posts
I have no idea what the quality of the Tivo DVR will be, but in the years that we had (and still have) SD Tivos, combined we didn't have to restart them as many times as we've had to restart one HR21-700 in the past 9 months. I think in the long run the Tivos will be excellent, and I hope that their quality will magically transfer to the HR21s.

Day one - fair. Day 180 - excellent.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
4,296 Posts
Redlinetire said:
You keep showing up in every TiVo speculation thread, complaining that it's speculation.

Do you not understand the concept of a discussion forum? :confused:

If you want news, ignore the threads and leave the discussion to those that want to talk...
Until there is a unit there is no point in the discussion of quality or blame for lack of quality.

Discussion is fine but this is pointless... you need hardware in your hands to criticize until then you are wasting your time.
 

· The Shadow Knows!
Joined
·
36,634 Posts
Some people here were around for the very first DirecTivos, before they had DLB. There were issues back then, and there were issues when I jumped onto the TiVo Bandwagon in 2003. I do expect the hardware side to be pretty mature, but I am willing to bet the software side will have to climb the same slope that Series3Tivos, ComcasTivos, and HR2x DVRs are climbing.

18 months after it's released, meaning potentially the summer of '11, they ought to have a pretty decent handle on it.
 

· Godfather
Joined
·
401 Posts
It will have bugs like the hr series had at first. I had one sd tivo for directv and it had the 6.3e software on it and it rebooted 3 times a week. Now this is after they have had these models out for years. I have 2 hr series when it comes out I will probably try one out just for the fun of a new box. I agree with Stuart it will be a few years for it to work great. I was one of the first with the hr20 and it took about 8 months to finally not have any major issues.
 
1 - 20 of 40 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top