DBSTalk Forum banner

If you get an HR34 - What Client would you want?

1 - 20 of 44 Posts

·
Geek til I die
Joined
·
9,821 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
With the upcoming release of RVU clients on the horizon, I wanted to see how many people were interested. Assuming you have or receive an HR34, would you prefer your extra rooms to have an RVU client which takes a tuner away from the HR34, or an H25 with its own tuner, or a DVR which adds two more tuners.

If you want a mixed system (say 1 RVU tv, and a couple H25's, choose both)

All currently cost the same per room per month.
 

·
The Shadow Knows!
Joined
·
37,060 Posts
At this point in time, the DVR. a few months from now, RVU probably.
 

·
Hall Of Fame
Joined
·
8,721 Posts
"Davenlr" said:
With the upcoming release of RVU clients on the horizon, I wanted to see how many people were interested. Assuming you have or receive an HR34, would you prefer your extra rooms to have an RVU client which takes a tuner away from the HR34, or an H25 with its own tuner.
Both cost the same per room per month.
There seems to be pluses and minuses to both.

RVU gives you trick play features for live TV but you have to share one of the 34's tuners, you could run into conflicts there. The H25 gives you it's own tuner, but you lose the trick play features.

It would be neat if they could come up with a way where you could chose between sharing a tuner with trick play or using its own tuner. Of course only us on here would know how to do that. ;)
 

·
Honi Soit Qui Mal Y Pense.
Joined
·
15,541 Posts
I chose the H25, as I am well fixed for DVRs, esp with the hypothetical HR34, and I love the compactness of the unit, and no noise from HDDs.

Yeah, and if the 25 could be either strictly a client of the RVU or its own receiver, that'd be truly awesome. - er, by our toggle, not a permanent set!
 

·
Legend
Joined
·
262 Posts
I am going to repurpose one of my existing HR20s as my client. I'll set it to one tuner to avoid going over the 8 tuner limit.

Here's my (proposed) configuration:

HR35 - in Family Room (5 tuners) - Recording shared shows for my wife and I
HR24 - in Family Room (2 tuners) - Recording my wife's shows only
HR20 - in exercise room (1 tuner) - Recording shows on SyFy channel only
 

·
Mentor
Joined
·
39 Posts
"Davenlr" said:
With the upcoming release of RVU clients on the horizon, I wanted to see how many people were interested. Assuming you have or receive an HR34, would you prefer your extra rooms to have an RVU client which takes a tuner away from the HR34, or an H25 with its own tuner, or a DVR which adds two more tuners.
I really like my H25, so in my ideal configuration - I would use 2 H25s for both live TV viewing and occasional watching of pre-recorded shows on the HR35.

I am also a big fan of Samsung LED TVs - I got a C8000 Series TV. I would like to eventually upgrade two TVs to RVU compatible LED models.

To summarize - 5 TVs in the house would look as follows:

1 HR35 Server
2 RVU Clients
2 H25 Clients/Standalone Receivers
 

·
Hall Of Fame
Joined
·
16,344 Posts
The ideal would also involve us being able to access the todo lists and series manager from another box, computer, phone or tablet. At least some of those,might now we've got none.
 

·
Legend
Joined
·
136 Posts
"dpeters11" said:
The ideal would also involve us being able to access the todo lists and series manager from another box, computer, phone or tablet. At least some of those,might now we've got none.
Is this something that can be done from the RVU client?
 

·
Legend
Joined
·
155 Posts
I voted DVR. DVR gives you the whole enchilada. I have become so spoiled with DVR.

The RVU won't be appealing to me until it becomes wireless and/or a client box instead of specific TV models.

I miss the DVR functions on the H25. H25 is nice being compact and all but I have a little beef with this unit. The extra rf kit adds an extra $30 to the purchase and the brick and rf add to the real estate the unit needs. By the time you add these the H24 has it is really at a wash IMO. I am going to try to hang it off the back of one of my TVs, I think that is where it will be handy. I wanted for tailgate type events and used my DVR in the past was concerned I would crash a hard drive.

Sorry for my rant. :grin:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
23,065 Posts
If such a box existed, I'd vote for an H25 with enough extra memory for a 30-minute buffer and a Smart Search database.

In reality, I voted for a DVR. This allows the HR34's tuners to record up to 5 simultaneous shows, if need be, and provides me with a LIVE BUFFER and SMART SEARCH on the client.

If there was an HR34 successor with 8 tuners, I might vote for 3-4 RVU boxes instead.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
14,514 Posts
I voted DVR/H25, as I'd prefer that the client user not steal a tuner from the HR34. But that's exactly opposite of how and why DIRECTV designed the HR34 to work with the thinnest possible client (an RVU device) so it will be curious if my choice ends up being the norm or the exception with the DBSTalk voters...
 

·
Honi Soit Qui Mal Y Pense.
Joined
·
15,541 Posts
alexginga said:
I like your sense of humor. In the ideal world - money is not an object here. We are talking IDEAL DirecTV setup.. :)
Oh, I didn't get that. In which case, I'd get all new Sammys plus the H25 for each one hooked up so I could switch inputs readily from RVU to H25 playing straight up or DVRing off the one of the 6 34's or eighteen other HR24's. I didn't see such an option in the poll.....

:D

Seriously, Alex, have you x-ed out plasmas altogether?
 

·
Geek til I die
Joined
·
9,821 Posts
Discussion Starter · #16 ·
Drew2k said:
I voted DVR/H25, as I'd prefer that the client user not steal a tuner from the HR34. But that's exactly opposite of how and why DIRECTV designed the HR34 to work with the thinnest possible client (an RVU device) so it will be curious if my choice ends up being the norm or the exception with the DBSTalk voters...
This is exactly my reason for the poll. Im feeling that by charging $6 for RVU *and* swiping a tuner, no one is going to want to go that route. We will see.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
23,065 Posts
Davenlr said:
This is exactly my reason for the poll. Im feeling that by charging $6 for RVU *and* swiping a tuner, no one is going to want to go that route. We will see.
No way they're not gonna charge for extra viewing locations, IMHO. That said, what wouldn't surprise me is the ability some day to buy "simultaneous" RVU licenses. So if you had 5 RVU-capable displays, e.g., but you know you'd never watch more than 2 of them at a time, you might only need to pay whatever the charge is for 2 seats.
 

·
Chancellor
Joined
·
9,094 Posts
I've said this before, I'll say it again:

My plan is to have one (1) HR34, and two (2) HR24-100s.
My wish would be to have two (2) HR34s, and one (1) HR24-100.
If money was less of an issue, I'd have three (3) HR34s, and one C30.

Of course, if I were to use alexginga's reasoning (money being no object), I'd have three (3) HR34s hooked up to three (3) Samsung RVU HDTV's, with an additional Samsung RVU HDTV connected to one of the HR34s.

Of course, if I were to take alexginga's reasoning further, if money weren't an object, I'd be living in a different place, and my TV viewing needs would be completely different... as would the needs of my hypothetical wife I would have thanks to the fact that money is no object to me. :D :p :D

I really like the last hypothetical scenario the best! :D

~Alan
 

·
Hall Of Fame
Joined
·
4,585 Posts
I choose DVR and H25 since I already have those. None of our TVs are older than 3 years so I don't see replacing any for a while. Too much $$$. If I needed an extra client location, I wouldn't mind trying the C30, especially if it was a lesser used TV. I'm sure we could spare at least one tuner. :D
 

·
Hall Of Fame
Joined
·
2,401 Posts
Don't' a few people already have RVU (Samsung TV) clients for free (no monthly fee)? If not, wouldn't anyone be out of his mind to pay the same for an RVU client as a DVR?
 
1 - 20 of 44 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top